Loved it

Me too. Not sure why the critics hated it so much.

I liked it too...but mainly because of all the good acting. The story wasn't very good.

I fell head over heels for this one. And I think my heart has never bled more for a Bale character since 3:10 to Yuma. I so look forward to wait some months before rewatching! Some wonderful times everything feels right, and for me, it was this gem. Loved the secret service / intelligent bird watching guys! Could they be more eccentric and easily enraged if they tried, specially the American?

It's okay but the editing and storytelling is very inconsistent. There's a gigantic flashback that stops the movie dead for twenty minutes. Also, not sure why it was rated R, as there is no foul language or sex. Maybe the WW1 flashbacks? This was the tamest R rated movie I saw in a long time.