MovieChat Forums > Megalopolis (2024) Discussion > This was a goddamn mess. 3/10

This was a goddamn mess. 3/10


I really was excited for it, but there is no getting around that this film is just an incoherent mess. You can see the ideas there, but FFC is just too far up his own ass to pull back on any of them. It's not an interesting or compelling story and is way more goofy than the trailer leads on and not in a good way. At times it's boring and then at others it's so batshit crazy I couldn't believe what I was watching. If anything it really is one of the most bizarre films I've seen in a long time, but man it was kind of sad watching this knowing it was made by one of the greatest directors of our time who is clearly off his rocker now.

reply

I'll be seeing it tonight. I had high hopes about a year ago but everything since then has made my hopes dwindle. I was hoping this would be something more like Beau Is Afraid or Babylon, an ambitious movie that usually makes no sense but is at least one-of-a-kind and incredible in its own regard. I know Beau Is Afraid wasn't everyone's cup of tea but you cant deny the integrity and the dreamlike craftsmanship of that movie. Now I'm feeling this will be more like Southland Tales, or what would happen if Tommy Wiseau were handed a sheet of LSD and $120 million to make a blockbuster.

reply

There are enough quality critics hailing it or saying it's entertaining enough, so keep an open mind.

I'm sure it's overstuffed but, then, so was "Apocalypse Now," not to mention "Youth Without Youth."

reply

It's not an interesting or compelling story and is way more goofy than the trailer leads on and not in a good way. At times it's boring and then at others it's so batshit crazy I couldn't believe what I was watching.

I thought the premise was both interesting and compelling. However, the implementation was exactly as you describe. I had the same feeling.

reply

It reminded me a lot of THE FIFTH ELEMENT in being a visually stunning film filled with irritating characters and a plot that only had me 15% invested into it (also I largely didn't quite get what was going on). However TFE had a lot more action, a stronger sci fi setting, and didn't have nearly this many red herrings and unanswered questions.

Why was NYC suddenly patterned after The Roman Republic? Why could Driver pause time and why didn't he ever seem to actually use it to his benefit? What was the whole point of that Megalon substance anyway, other than being some miracle way to heal himself? What did his character even do for a job anyway and why did all these women fawn over him when he was consistently aloof and not seem to care about anyone or anything? It would have been a much more interesting movie if it was set entirely in a Megalopolis (rather than only showing up in the end) and if the time-pausing special ability was actually used by the characters to further the plot in any significant way.

reply

Yes. All of this.

"It would have been a much more interesting movie if it was set entirely in a Megalopolis (rather than only showing up in the end) and if the time-pausing special ability was actually used by the characters to further the plot in any significant way." Along with some insight into the Megalon.

reply

Why was NYC suddenly patterned after The Roman Republic?


Coppola was updating Lucius Sergius Catiline's failed attempt to take control of the Roman republic in 63 BC in which he lost to his rival Marcus Tullius Cicero. Thus NYC in his movie is New Rome in an alternative America.

Why could Driver pause time and why didn't he ever seem to actually use it to his benefit?


It wasn't a literal power, but a metaphor for the ability of artists to 'stop time' when they're focused on creating. In other words, when visionaries create, everything else freezes. Cesar Catilina used this 'power' to his benefit to successfully create Megalopolis.

What was the whole point of that Megalon substance anyway


It was symbolic of faith and ties into the line: "When you jump into the unknown, you prove you are free." Megalopolis would not come to exist without faith. And Cesar wouldn't receive healing for his (apparently) mortal wound without faith.

What did his character even do for a job


He was an architect and the director of the City Design department.

why did all these women fawn over him


Because he was talented, intelligent, wealthy and brooding, not to mention successful, a Nobel Prize winner and a major celebrity in New Rome. Did you see his posh penthouse? He was also tall, dark and not-so-handsome (two out of three ain't bad). Such factors would naturally attract a few beautiful women.

It would have been a much more interesting movie if it was set entirely in a Megalopolis


That would indeed be an interesting movie, but this film is about what it takes to create a 'Megalopolis' (faith in one's vision, perseverance, finding loyal loved ones, uniting and overcoming personal flaws), as well as the consequences of carrying it out (persecution, slander and working with those hostile toward you/your vision).

It goes even deeper than that, but I'll stop there. The movie's an entertaining cinematic parable with several interesting insights from which to mull over and glean.

reply