MovieChat Forums > Gomorra (2009) Discussion > This movie is NOT gritty in the least bi...

This movie is NOT gritty in the least bit!


I do not get why this movie is called 'gritty' on this board. There is nothing the least bit gritty about it.

Gritty seems to be a buzzword used as a selling point for why this movie is good, yet it is not gritty, so does that make it in actuality not good? Does this movie have any other selling points that it does not fail with, like it does with 'gritty?'

Other than some random deaths of characters we know absolutely nothing about in the first few scenes, and there is nothing new in the depiction of those deaths that make them gritty, almost nothing else happens. The two times after that that something does happen, the only other parts of the movie that could be remotely be considered 'gritty,' are almost completely off-screen, and entirely off-screen.

The movie instantly cuts away after the muzzle flash when the mom gets shot. Is that supposed to be gritty? It's not. A much more gritty depiction of the exact same thing was shown in The Godfather II way back in 1974, which IIRC didn't cut away like Gomorra does. That is to say, Gomorra has far less grittiness than a comparable movie made in 1974.

In fact, The Godfather I is also way, way more gritty than Gomorra.

Then with the deaths of the two idiot cokehead thugs, it is entirely off-screen. Showing them die on-screen wouldn't have been gritty anyway, but the way they die off-screen is nothing short of pathetic.

Calling Gomorra gritty is a totally inaccurate statement.

reply

You seem to be a little obsessed with grit, why don't you buy a big bag of it, tie it around your ankles and find a convenient pier to launch yourself off. Sorry, but if your sole observation of a interesting, provoking and realistic movie is to find it UN-Gritty, then I guess your chances of becoming an articulate and insightful film critic are somewhere below zero. Oh, and theres a Building Material Sale on at Homebase if you are running short of your favourite Aggregate.

reply

lol just noticed you have posted a comment on the movie "true grit"

reply

What a hilarious *beep* reply. Well worded sir.

reply

hahaha! Perfect reply.


Do not click on this link without my permission: http://meonvarioustopics.blogspot.com

reply

"You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means." - Inigo Montoya

reply

It's a well known fact that a rusty piece of metal has to appear in a movie for it to ever be considered gritty.

reply

[deleted]