MovieChat Forums > Los abrazos rotos (2010) Discussion > Did I compeletely missunderstand this!?

Did I compeletely missunderstand this!?


After a friend watched the movie i was discussing it with her and our opinions about what happened in the movie were completely different. So i would be happy to hear what you thought happened.

The way i understood it is that when Lena is seeking help from her boss in the beginning of the movie to care for her sick father that is after the car accident with Harry. And that in that car accident where harry became blind Lena did not die but merely saw this as an opportunity to start over. And Judith hence lies about her being dead to Harry since he would never find out the truth, in order to protect him from Lena (which she despised) and also protect Lena from him.

Maybe i am completely wrong... but that how i remembered the movie anyways... please share your thoughts...

reply

Please can anyone shine some light upon this?

reply

The official synopsis:

A man lives, writes and loves in the dark. Fourteen years ago he suffered a brutal car accident in the island of Lanzarote (Canary Islands, Spain). In the accident, not only he lost his sight, but also lost the woman of his life, Lena.

This man uses two names Harry Caine, playful pseudonym under which he signs his literary works, stories and scripts, and Mateo Blanco, his real name, under which he lives and he signs the films directed by him. After the accident, Mateo Blanco is reduced to his pseudonym, Harry Caine.

He cannot direct movies; he is suffering from the burden of losing his lover, and he likes to think that he also died in that horrible accident.

So Harry Caine basically lives thanks to the scripts he writes and because of the help of his old and faithful Prodution Director, Judit García; and Diego, son of Judit, a typist and secretary. Diego is also Mateo's guide, as he is completely blind.

Ever since he decided to live in order to tell stories, Harry became an active and attractive blind man who has strengthened his other senses to enjoy his life, with high dosages of irony and a self-inducted amnesia. He has completely erased the first identity of his biography, Mateo Blanco.

One night Diego has an accident and Harry looks after him (his mother, Judit, is out of Madrid, and they decide not to tell her about the accident in order to not alarm her). During the first nights of convalescence, Diego asks Harry to tell him about the time at which he responded to the name of Mateo Blanco. Harry is taken aback at first, but he finally accepts to tell Diego about the incidents that took place fourteen years ago, in order to entertain the boy. He begins to tell him the tale, like a father would do for his little child to fall asleep.

The tale of Judit, Lena, Mateo and Ernesto Martel is an amour fou story, dominated by the fatality, the jealousy, the abuse authority, the treason and the guilty complex. An exciting and terrible story; its more expressive image is the single photo of two lovers embraced, torn up into a thousand pieces.

There is also a plot summary on the film's Wikipedia page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_Embraces

reply

It's an interesting theory, but if I recall the chronology correctly it was because Lena needed money for her father's care that she went back to prostitution. This was all back in the early 90s according to the caption that flashed up on the screen.

Harry/Mateo was not on the scene at all yet, because he didn't meet her until after she took up acting when she had become bored of being a kept woman a couple of years later.

If the hospital scene was after the accident, I would have expected Lena to at least have a limp or visible scar because her side of the car took the full force of an accident that left Harry/Mateo blind.

I suppose it might be a case of Almodovar playing with the chronology, because it does put a twist in the tale (how would a blind person know for sure his lover was dead) but I think it's cruel enough that a) he lost Lena and b) he can't even see her again on film or in a photo.

I'll have to watch the scene again for any clues. For instance, maybe the mum looks older?

reply

Yes, you completely misunderstood it.
the first few scenes tell you how Lena became the rich man's lover, because she was desperate because of her father's cancer. It's also clear that by the time Lena meets Mateo, she not only accepted help but was the rich man's full-time mistress, living with him. She mentions something about living with him for two years, and it's very likely that Lena's father is already dead by then.
Also, after the accident, Judit tells Mateo that Lena has been buried next to her father.

reply

You are indeed completely wrong. No idea how you could come up with that.

__________________________
www.1up-games.com Last seen:

reply