MovieChat Forums > Persuasion (2008) Discussion > modern language slip-ups?

modern language slip-ups?


When Mary is arguing to stay with Louisa because Anne is "nothing" to her, she states why should Anne stay while I am sent packing?

DId they use this term in this era?!! It seems like a screenwriter slip up to me.

reply

From what I just read, Shakespeare used this expression in Henry IV.

http://currentscene.wordpress.com

reply

Thanks, Julie-30! Your postings have been very informative, I just subscribed to your blog.

I think I'm used to Downton Abbey putting so much modern language in that I'm immediately suspect when I hear something that sounds off now.

reply

When P&P95 came out, people thought the use of "fudge" to mean "mess up" was anachronistic. Apparently, it wasn't.

And thank you for your kind words. My blog hasn't been updated in a while (Real Life has gotten in the way), but I do still check for comments, etc.

http://currentscene.wordpress.com

reply

I tried to google the origin of this term, and found this:

https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/75676/phrase-origin-sent-packing

According to the OED, this is related to the transitive sense of to pack oneself meant to leave with your belongings, particularly when dismissed. It dates from around 1450.

An intransitive to pack is similarly to depart hurriedly or ignominiously, also from around 1450 in An Alphabet of Tales:

Þis pure man went vnto his howse & stude at þe dure & askid almos; So þis Peirs bad hym pakk & said he sulde hafe none.

And with send, as usually used today, from around 1580 in J. Jeffere's Bugbears:

I sent the knaves packinge.


And like Julie said, Shakespeare used "send packing" a few years later in Henry IV.

Because my mind works in mysterious ways, I also tried to decipher what that cryptically spelt first quote meant and came up with:

This pure man went unto his house and stood at the door and asked alms; So this Peirs bid him pack (=told him to leave) and said he should have none (=he wouldn't get any)

Does that sound about right?

reply