MovieChat Forums > The Lost Room (2006) Discussion > Similarities with LOTR ?!

Similarities with LOTR ?!


Any similarity with the scripts ?!

Two carriers whose main aim is not the objects, but to use them for their aim. (Joe-Karl/Frodo-Sam)
One weak character who is captured by the charm of objects. (Dr.Martin/Gollum)
A group of people who wants to destroy the objects (The Legion/The Fellowship)
A group who wants to seize the objects to use them for their own. (The Order/Sauron-Saruman)

Objects are calling each other.
Using them is disastrous.

And an endless diplomacy :)

These are the things I can remember for now. If anyone finds anything else, please write it down here.

Care your selves fella !

reply

I don't see the parallelism between the Lost Room and the Lord of the Rings, except for the fact that the plot revolves around objects of power, one being the primary one. Besides, Frodo had no personal agenda with the ring's destruction, save for the wellbeing of the free peoples of Middle Earth, along with the fact that his uncle Bilbo gave it to him. In THe Lost Room, Joe just wanted to get his daughter back, but wasn't motivated by the agenda's of the The Legion/the Order... even though he became associated with them.

Another discrepancy between the two storylines is that in The Lord of the Rings, the rings were intentionally made for the powers they granted their weilders. In The Lost Room, there is no idication that the objects were created with the purpose of weilding power over other people, let alone that they were intentionally created by anyone at all.

There are similarities, but parallelism?

reply

Yeah, infact thats right! Sorry, for my exegesis. No parallelisim but, let say, similarities.

reply

"I don't see the parallelism between the Lost Room and the Lord of the Rings"

You don't? Silly rabbit, it's all very clear.



1. Too much free time.
2. Social awkwardness.
3. Possible obesity.
4. Bad complexion.
5. Chronic nerdism.
6. Halitosis.
7. Fantasy world begins to slip into waking hours.
8. Omega-male syndrome.
9. There is no #9.
10.Excessive masturbation (w/ or w/o Nacho Cheese stained fingers).



When someone is plagued by some, or all, of these symptoms, the parallels between films, shows, and their own daydreams will be both plentiful, and also have great significance and solidity.

reply

I disagree... it find it it more like "The Ninth Gate"

There are books instead of objects to collect for in concert, will open a gate to another dimension.

There is an order which are a cult to the books.

I don't think thay used the The Ninth Gate as a model but I find both are similar in many ways...

"...If you have an issue, here a tissue"

reply

[deleted]

HA HA HA, that is some great comedy.

reply

See the work of Joseph Campbell, Lord Raglan & others - there are only so many plots in the world.

And if you want similarities to the Lord of the Rings, check out Wagner's Ring Cycle.

reply

That is reaching pretty far trying to find similarities.

reply

If you look hard enough you often find similarities from nothing

reply