MovieChat Forums > Se, jie (2007) Discussion > Explicit sexuality is the only thing tha...

Explicit sexuality is the only thing that made this movie stand out..


Being eastern european and seen the movies ive seen, sex was the least of its problems. As a matter of fact, that type of explicit sexuality was pertinent to the plot and the characters. I was more dissappointed with the story. Very unorignal and uninspiring. The obvious cliches, predictable ending, and most of the time flat personalities, I expected way more from Ang Lee.



Dont feed the trolls!!

reply

You know what, this could be quite true! I also found some of it bordering on comical: the extravagance of a couple of scenes (the stabbing scene and the more erotic sex scene) made me chuckle in their quasi-absurdity.

reply

Have you ever killed a man before? I hope not. Neither have I, but I imagine that it would take more than a quick stab/slash with a short knife, as how most hollywood movies would portray a killing. In the movie, it was the moment when the group of students finally realized that it's no longer a school play anymore. It was bloody, messy, and real. A powerful climax to wrap up the first half of the film.

As for the OP, I tend to think that the explicit sex scenes which you claim to be accustomed to are exactly why you've been distracted from the heart of the movie. Not that I blame you, for some western friends of mine hold similar opinions towards the film.

This film excels in showing the subtle struggles of love, lust and fear inside the main characters' hearts, set against an extraordinary historical background. Think Brokeback Mountain with espionage. With Ang Lee, there's always more than meets the eye, always a subtext to explore. The opening scene of mahjong game alone could be the material for a whole semester of film studies. It pains me that the average westerner would possibly never fully appreciate how much Lee and the actors have accomplished with this masterpiece, for it's such an exquisite study of humanity.

reply

you're not honestly saying that Mr. Yee and Wang Jiazhi's characters are flat now...

reply

[deleted]

It is the complexity of Mr Yee and Ms Mak that made this film stand out as well as the superb direction of Ang Lee.

reply