MovieChat Forums > Se, jie (2007) Discussion > RESPONSE TO GOOFS; RE: BUICKS USED

RESPONSE TO GOOFS; RE: BUICKS USED


In the movie goof remarks a contributor goofed. There are two Buicks in this movie. The one that appears first at one minute and eleven seconds into the movie - there are three cars in this scene and the last one is the topic of discussion - and the same one again appears at one hour fifty-nine minutes and thirty seconds is a 1950 Buick. This car is easily identified by the grill and parking light in both scenes, but only in the first appearance can the windshield be clearly seen and that presents a problem because in the movie the windshield is a two piece windshield but the 1950 Buick was a single piece windshield. It appears the producers of the movie retrofitted a two piece since in the time period of the movie (approximately 1939-1942) there were no automobiles with one piece windshields.

The other Buick that appears is also the one that is shown in all the movie trailers I've seen for Lust, Caution, apparently driving the streets of Shanghai. It is a four door and it also appears two times in the movie. This Buick is a 1947 Roadmaster, not a 1948 Buick as described in the "goof" remarks. In addition, the referenced "gun-sight" hood ornament made famous by Buick, as were the three "vent holes" that appear on the fender which trademarked Buicks for many years (and have been re-established for the current top of the line Buick Lucerne), this "gun-sight" hood ornament was first used on the 1946 Buick, not the 1948 model. We can identify the Buick in question by two features. First, there is a large badge/emblem (larger than the same badge/emblem on the 1946 Buick) that appears above the "waterfall" grill, (again a traditional Buick feature). This was first used on the 1947 Roadmaster, and again on the Roadmaster in 1948, however the waterfall grill on the 1947 model is taller in height (as in the movie) than the 1948 grill but with the identical badge above. While the Buick Super of both years were substantially the same as the Roadmaster, it is more likely the longer Roadmaster would be used by higher echelon individuals, just as with Chrysler the New Yorker was a upper moder, but if available, the Imperial would be more likely chosen by the more elevated positions of an organization be it in the business world or high government officials.

How or why movie producers make these critical errors is unfathomable. When you are told the time era of a movie and immediately see these Buicks it is distracting; the same as many movies that depict a certain period but the pop music being played in the background is not of the same time.

reply

I don't think its a goof, many western cars were imported into China before and during this time. In fact, its been said that Buick was secretly Mao Zedongs favorite car..

reply

Buicks have always been among the most popular cars in China. Even today they are the number 1 0r 2 seller of all makes. However, that isn't the issue. The issue is the movie takes place 1939-1942/3 and 1947 and 1950 Buicks are being used. That is a goof.

This "goof" is a distraction, however, since I bought the NC-17 version, I have enjoyed the movie many times. Thus, the distraction has not prevented me from appreciating the story and the conflicting emotions of the two main characters and the juxtaposition they find themselves trapped within.

reply

The reason for my familiarity of these Buicks is it's my favorite, ever since my folks owned a maroon 1946 4-door Buick Super. Have many pictures of that first car to be my "car". The subsequent years of 1947-48 the Buick remained substantially similar.

As for the movie, I own the NC-17 version and have watched it innumerable times. A great movie and enjoy it each time I watch. The failure to be authentic as to the Buicks does not hamper my finding the movie a love and die plot that intrigues me and retains my interest repeatedly.

I have shared this movie with my 18 year-old granddaughter while skipping the sexual scenes, so I have to somewhat describe that action and it's importance to the story and letting her watch and listen as Tang Wei details her relationship with Yee and then her singing essentially a love song from her heart to him. Then with the purchasing of a "quail egg" qualifying diamond ring from him to her, one cannot deny how these two have found a certain safety being close to the other while their unintended emotions evolve into a love for the other. While she saves him, he cannot save her.

So when all is done my granddaughter did enjoy immensely the movie too.

Thanks for your comments but wanted you to know I thought the movie is great.

reply

Have to agree - while I don't know my Buicks as well as you and never would have caught that error, the London Taxi floored me. I actually grabbed screen shots to show my husband (we drive them as our everyday cars).

reply

Wow, very informative! Thank you for posting!
:)

reply