MovieChat Forums > Jericho (2006) Discussion > 'have you tried typing a straight IP add...

'have you tried typing a straight IP address'... Hahahahahaha....


As someone who works in technology, I had a good laugh when one girl is attempting to check her email and the other girl shows up and asks - Have you tried typing a straight IP Address? And then proceeds to type in 827.750.304.001

Bwahahahahahahahaha....

First off, all computers use IP addresses because that is what the machines know and work off of. Since humans cannot easily remember these 4 octet bytes (for IPv4) of numbers, DNS was created to give them easily rememberable names like mail.yahoo.com translating to some IP address.

So, ordinarily you won't expect people to know these "straight IP addresses" by heart like how she types it out.
And the fact that she cannot connect doesn't mean in that situation that her DNS is down... goddamn it, the connectivity is not there....

And the IP she types is also all nonsense. It is not even valid.


Gaaah... I hate it when people cannot hire a proper tech consultant and get basic things correct.

There are other things wrong with the show about the bombs, radiation, medicine etc. and I'm sure people in those fields also must be going nuts...

What a moronic show

reply

Yes, I'd rather they hire a bunch of consultants to make the show as accurate as possible, and then hire discount writers to pen the scripts and use cardboard special effects. Realism is important but it is very far from the most important thing.

It's fiction. If you can't look past minor flubb ups then I fear there is very little entertainment out there for you.

---
"Pride is not the opposite of shame, but its source. True humility is the antidote to shame."

reply

Well, what is your field of work?

If say you're a doctor, and they show nonsense, would you get peeved and laugh at it or just ignore it?

Some might not.

There's other examples of people in a particular field and making posts like mine where Hollywood doesn't get basic things right.

Here's an example of a recent movie - http://pro.imdb.com/title/tt2024469/board/nest/227063241

I know it is fiction. I am willing to suspend my belief. To you, this is a minor flub because (assuming) you are not a tech person and don't understand these things. To me, because it is my field, I think it is laughable and I am saying there are ways to get it right.

I did get my entertainment from it. I LOL'd at it even more. I was entertained even more than you.

reply

The saying is "suspend DISbelief."

reply

Jumping in on an old thread.

I think it is just the opposite. The things you actually know something about are where you have to be able to really suspend disbelief or else you can't enjoy virtually any show. I always just expect that almost every aspect of computing, from 99% of all computers being from Apple to every system on Earth being easily hackable by anyone that can recognize a keyboard, will be wrong. The Terminator was programmed in COBoL - yup, I can accept that. A tech group irretrievably deleted 1/3 of a leading porn websites database by accidentally placing something on a delete key - okay, that one hurt, but I soldiered on.

I know nothing about military customs and weapons and fighting styles, but I know from the message boards that if I did I'd have to adopt the same attitude in a lot of the shows I watch.

Same with medicine and don't even get them started on the legal shows which might be the only field more mangled on TV than tech.

It's the price of entertainment.


"Every news story is 100% correct except the ones you know anything about."

reply

Yeah, I do agree, I did cringe a bit when they did the first three-octets.

They could've at least stuck to the basics of each octet not exceeding '255' in value. I'd have been fine with seing a '255.255.255.255' Class D address over '827.750.304.001'. Robert being in satellite installation would have had him familiar with some of those terms, so I'd imagine his daughter being familiar isn't too bad a of stretch.

In fiction, though, we could just rule it out as that being the IP she tried typing, and the explanation being her lack of knowledge of IPs.

Hell, I'd have given it some leighway if it were even an IPv6 address, FFS, instead of one that has three-octets exceeding the numerical range for each octet's maximum quantity (1-255).

I do give Jericho the benefit of the doubt when believing if the girl (Robert's daughter, forgot her name), has a lack of knowledge and the IP she typed in wasn't a show error, but an error on her part for thinking she knows how to link with it. I'm not saying kids are stupid, but I'd like to believe, since it's not a bad stretch of it.


And no, I'm not really in technology much -- I just studied it while I was in the Army Rangers in between tours. I do like a lot of the field, so I'm not claiming all of what I wrote is fully correct.

reply

Of all the things wrong with this show, that is just another one... LOL

"I'd take the awe of understanding over the awe of ignorance any day." -Douglas Noel Adams

reply

They just enjoy insulting the audience's collective intelligence, instead of giving us the benefit of the doubt.

I'm fortunate the pylons were not set to a lethal level.

reply

well, this show is by the guy who brought us National Treasure, so...

reply

Seriously? It's not like they could use a "live" IP address. If they used an IP address starting with 169.*.*.* you'd have bitched about that too I imagine. They used a bogus IP to tell the story just like in most shows when you have to use a phone number the 3 digits after the area code are usually 555 because that is unused in any area code except for information calls.

People try this stuff out now because computers are everywhere. You wouldn't want them to make up an IP and accidentally give them yours would you? You'd be getting pinged so hard it would've brought your Internet provider down if not your own home server if you had one.

"Gaaah.... I hate it when people can't understand the story telling industry."

reply

THANK YOU WFOX-5!! I wondered if anyone was going to make the area code 555 comparison! Of course all the other supporting information is spot on, but yeah...

Darn kids! Give them one lousy local nuke and suddenly everyone is Ma Bell for IP addresses, right? Are you sure she didn't get the IP address wrong because she was female? or maybe because she was black? Maybe she should change tooth pastes?... Well, at least no body has to worry about prom this year

Merovingian Goddess
Gentlemen, you can't fight in here! This is the War Room!

reply

They could have used 192.168.1.1 - which is the default IP address for most routers. If any pranksters in the viewer audience wanted to try it, and anybody tried typing it in at home, they most often would either pull up nothing, or at worst get their own router asking them for its admin user ID and password.

''I'm fortunate the pylons were not set to a lethal level.''

reply

True but then the OP would've bitched about "of course that wouldn't work because thats your router IP" so its a lose/lose situation. (funny enough none of my routers ever use that Lol)

reply

by Shawnchapp - Mon May 9 2016 19:54 -
... OP would've bitched about "of course that wouldn't work because thats your router IP" ...
My router is 192.168.222.222, I customised the settings.

''I'm fortunate the pylons were not set to a lethal level.''

reply

ok? thats still in the range for private IP addresses 192.168.0.0 to 192.168.255.255... so even if the show used that OP still would've bitched about it being a router ip Lol

reply

You could argue the point the character actually has NFI but wanted to appear smart and helpful as the girls she was helping wouldn't know their arse from their elbow when it comes to tech.

I could yammer a similar line to someone like say my mum and type 123.456.789.0 and go "oooooh well the internet is broken"

reply