MovieChat Forums > La misma luna (2008) Discussion > for all those who say its anti-american ...

for all those who say its anti-american anti-caucasian etc.


I fail to see why this movie is antiamerican or the sort. The movie is just portraying the life of a family who is separated. Nowadays everything is made to have a political content, even if it's not the author's intention. You can make political content out of anything. I tell you a story about ants, and you can tell me it's a leftist story with a secret agenda blah blah blah..

Does the movie make the Immigration People look evil? Maybe. But the movie is only showing you THE PERSPECTIVE of illegal immigrants. Of course police seems kind of evil in the eyes of illegal immigrants, but that doesn't mean they are. The movie is only showing you a POV (POINT OF VIEW). And I can't think of one movie that is not showing you the perspective of at least one character.

It's a sad reality that so many people go to the USA looking for a better life. But it's a reality, so why is it bad to make an story out of it?
If we look at all movies only from a political perspective, then we wouldn't be able to film anything. Somewhere, someone would always be offended.


Did the filmmaker wanted to make a political point? I don't know. I just hope she just wanted to tell an story, because I think she did succeed in it. Good movie.

reply

yeah i agree with you. This movie was made so that it can show what it's like for immigrants who want to have a better life and make more money to support their kids. This film wasn't anti-american, if it was, it wouldn't have been released in america. This movie was made for americans, the type who have no sympathy for the immigrants with horrible lives wanting to have better ones. This is why the movie was made. Plus the people that help the little boy get across the border were AMERICAN, they were mexican, but still AMERICAN and wanted to help. It didn't portray americans bad, just the border patrol because i'm sure if these people were trying to take away my dreams, i wouldn't feel that they were very rich or extraordinary, or wanted to help make a difference in peoples lives. I'm not saying they are bad, but really i just don't like them. I'm american, proud to be, but I can't say 100% of the time I am. And don't even get me started on those who say "taking advantage of our rights". Dude so what?! Of course your gonna take advantage on a chance to improve your life so why the hell do they care?

Stay gold Ponyboy...stay gold
Johnny Cade
The Outsiders

reply