MovieChat Forums > Oorlogswinter (2008) Discussion > 'Coming of age'? SPOILERS

'Coming of age'? SPOILERS


PLOT SPOILERS FOLLOWING

This has been described as a "coming of age" type film - the boy "matures" in his attitudes about his family and the world, while losing his father and making big decisions, etc.
But is needlessly murdering his uncle by shooting him in the back also a part of "coming of age"?
His uncle was some kind of "collaborator", and I guess part of the boy's "coming of age" is his realising and evaluating the subtle differences between types of "collaboration/resistance" in his father and uncle. But is the uncle's collaboration used to justify the boy murdering him in cold blood (ie. not in self-defence, more out of "childish" anger than anything)?
Is this sort of senseless violence being accepted/promoted as part of "coming of age" for a normal person? (Or have I missed plot elements showing the uncle to be a threat to the boy, his family, or the airman's escape attempt?)

I'd be genuinely interested in comments, since it left me a bit confused as to what to think about the filmmakers' intentions/attitudes.

reply

He killed the uncle because he thought he was going to alert the Germans about Jack and his sister. The uncle had already proved untrustworthy with his previous actions.

reply

The uncle was a traitor and a spy. Now that the boy knew what his uncle was, the uncle was hardly going to let the boy live, nor was the boy going to keep it quiet.

reply

During that scene I was reminded of Tuco's words from "Good, Bad, and Ugly",: If you are going to shoot, shoot. Don't talk about it!" Good advice

reply

[deleted]