MovieChat Forums > The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian (2008) Discussion > If you liked Skandar Keynes as Edmund...

If you liked Skandar Keynes as Edmund...

posted 15 years ago by fkelleghan
2 replies | jump to latest

... then you are going to love Harry Treadaway, who acts in a fantastic role in City of Ember, which is a wonderful, amazing, thrilling film that's been terribly underestimated.

Harry Treadaway looks very like Skandar; I really thought it was Skandar until I realized the voice patterns were wrong. (Though Treadaway is also English; but he does a stunningly good American accent!)

Hey, cheers to all of my Skandar-loving friends!

Fiona Kelleghan

[–] gimmieacoookie 15 years ago

I don't think he looks like Skandar...

Skandar's more attractive :D

Loriginals#3
Typography
"Oh please, oh please, be my prisoner!"

[–] A_Bob 15 years ago

The problem with Harry in "Ember" was his age. His character, Doon, was supposed to be 12-years-old, or about as old as Saiorse Ronan (who was about 13-14 during filming). Harry was about 24 when during filming.

Had they just made Doon older, it would have been fine but they kept his character about 12-years-old which was off-putting for me.

Bob