MovieChat Forums > Silence (2017) Discussion > Wow I expected a preachy self indulgent ...

Wow I expected a preachy self indulgent jesus flick, this was excellent.


Holy crap this film blew me away. This movie became the exact opposite of what I was expecting. I am just so used to hateful pure flicks movies!

-They do not convert people and shame cultures, they simply offer services to people who are already christians.

-This movie does not portray the Japanese as evil godless savages that need a white savior.

-The film questions whether god is real or not!

-The film talks about cultural differences with translation. The fact that the Japanese do not worship jesus as a person, but rather nature itself. I also loved that the movie was book-ended with sounds of nature.

-Andrew was not that bad! I was ready for one of his worst performances and he actually was quite good.

-Padre Rodreguiz lives as a Japanese citizen for the rest of his life and ironically contributes to the slaughter of Chritians! I mean what an ending. It was a classic Scorsese rise and fall story that did not have some phony self-righteous morals pinned to the end. Brilliant and possibly the best religious film of all time.

reply

I really enjoyed it. Very smart film that isn't too emotionally manipulative. It was a little hard for me to sympathize with the priests though because I'm an atheist. I just don't get how faith can be so important to people that they can watch people suffer. But that's a problem with me, not the film.

reply

It is one of the deepest, most thought provoking, thematically intellectual films you are likely to see... its challenging nature is to its credit, not to its detriment.

In time, people will realize that this is a major masterpiece of art cinema.

And did I mention that it is visually staggering????

reply

You are right. Brilliant film.

reply

[deleted]