MovieChat Forums > Rogue (2007) Discussion > Review - Ain't It Cool News

Review - Ain't It Cool News


http://www.aintitcool.com/node/37792

Okay, well there's another movie coming to DVD this week called ROGUE. It was midnight meat trained onto a mere 10 screens in the US so to us it might as well be DTV. The cover just shows a giant bloody crocodile mouth along with two other "don't even consider watching this crap" signs: the Dimension Extreme logo and a giant "UNRATED" stamped under the title WITH BLOOD DRIPPING! I mean, can you even imagine how NOT rated this *beep* is, there is BLOOD DRIPPING OFF OF THE DESCRIPTION OF THE RATING! WHICH IN THIS CASE IS NOT A RATING AT ALL BUT IN FACT THE LACK OF A RATING! WITH BLOOD! HOLY *beep*!

What you have here is one of those covers designed to ward off the people who would enjoy the movie and attract the people who would not. This could definitely be R-rated, it's hardly a gorefest at all, it's not "extreme," and it's too bad the Weinsteins didn't let someone with taste and competence of some kind buy it. If those pricks had taken a 90 minute break from ruining everything they would've seen that it's not some *beep* CGI bloodfest, it's actually a very well-made Australian suspense thriller from Greg Mclean, director of WOLF CREEK. Definitely not something they would be interested in.

I know WOLF CREEK is a divisive movie. To me it's one of the better horror movies of recent years despite the anticlimactic ending, to most critics it's the most shocking and amoral filth that has ever been put on film, to some of my buddies it's just not very good. But even zero-stars Roger Ebert admitted it was well directed so hey, how 'bout if this guy does a movie about a big crocodile instead of a murderer? Will that appease you guys? Or do you think it will give crocodiles ideas?

I don't know about you but when I think "giant crocodile movie" I think crappy photography of some ugly swamp location, some bad actors, and way too many shots of a really bad CGI croc. This is the opposite. Believe it or not I think some people would enjoy it just for the photography and scenery. This has got to be the best use of HD in a horror movie to date because it looks like Attenborough's PLANET EARTH series. The story follows a tour boat down a river in the northern territory of Australia, and they work in all this amazing footage of animals, insects and incredible natural landscapes.

Instead of trying to make everything fast and noisy like so many youths do, McClean has an old school cinematic feel. I was hooked before anything even happened, just from the dialogue-free opening minutes of star Michael Vartan (21st century Luke Perry) getting out of a bus in the middle of nowhere, smoking a cigarette and walking into a little tavern with gory croc attack newspaper clippings on the wall. This guy is a travel writer, but not an adventurer. A professional tourist. This has some of the same themes as WOLF CREEK: tension between locals and tourists, and the natural beauty and spookiness of Australia.

Vartan goes on this tour boat, and just as they're about to turn back and head home somebody spots a flare. They go further down the river than they should to check it out and get attacked and stranded by this giant crocodile. Actually I should say large crocodile, because this one is 7 meters long and Mclean informs us on the extras that there is a real one somewhere that's 7.5 meters. They use the metric system in Australia, by the way, I don't know how many feet that is but it's alot in my opinion.

The croc is kind of like JAWS, he is mostly a menacing unseen presence. Usually when he eats somebody (which is surprisingly often) it happens so quick you barely see it. Later you do get a good look at him and there's enough animatronics and restrained enough animation that it looks pretty real. They make him move like a real animal, this is not like those speed fiend CGI gators in ERASER.

You know, this could've easily been retooled into DISNEY'S THE JUNGLE CRUISE. It looks like the same boat and everything. But then they would've had to have Eddie Murphy or somebody as the captain instead of the lovely Radha Mitchell.

Mclean gets some great suspense out of the different escape plans they come up with. There were times that the sudden devouring of characters off camera without much mourning started to stretch the realism, and James Cameron's homie Sam Worthington's instant flip from *beep* to hero seemed a little drastic. But every time I thought it might be losing its steam suddenly something would happen that would make me say "Oh *beep* It's a very tense movie.

And you know it's not just that it's an effective thriller, it also has these little touches here and there that you just don't expect in a large to giant crocodile picture. Like there's this character Russell, played by an unrecognizable John Jarrat (the killer from WOLF CREEK, now meek and wearing a fake belly). When he gets on the boat he has two tickets, but he's by himself. He doesn't really explain it and you wonder what that's all about. He's very quiet. Later, when they're all enjoying the beauty of nature and *beep* and he thinks nobody's looking he takes out a small urn and pours some ashes over the side. Clearly his loss is an important part of where he's coming from as a character, but they never have him talk about it directly, and the little girl on the boat is the only one who even finds out about it.

reply

Another review at http://moviepulse.net/mp_pages/dvd/page_rogue.php

O.K. Bob and Harvey, please explain to me why Rogue, the best water based horror film since Jaws, didn’t get a wide theatrical release? Combining sheer terror with the gorgeous locales of the Outback, writer/director Greg McClean has made a beautifully engrossing, nail biting film that deserved far more then the ten domestic theaters it received.

When a flare is spotted by a tourist on a crocodile cruise in the heart of the Australian Outback, Kate (Radha Mitchell) turns her boat around to help the distressed individual. Feeling safe inside their boat from the croc infested waters, the cruise unknowingly enters the territory of an extremely hostile crocodile. After capsizing the boat, the crocodile forces the passengers to take refuge on a small tideland island. With the water quickly rising, and a giant killer hunting them from beneath the murky water, Kate and travel reporter Pete McKell (Michael Vartan) must find a way to help get these people to safety.

While his previous effort, Wolf Creek, made you tremble at the idea of being stranded in the middle of the Outback’s desert landscape, writer/director Greg McClean’s Rogue will have you terrified to put even your big toe into Australian waters. Showing an incredible amount of tact, the leaps and bounds that Greg McClean has grown as a filmmaker since his previous effort are astounding. Where Wolf Creek offered uneven pacing and little to no restraint when it came to building up cathartic tension, McClean manages to grab the audiences attention from the get go with Rogue and never lets go.

The filmmaker accomplishes this by using several classic cinematic techniques, most notably the ticking clock. With the tide quickly rising, and the killer croc claiming victims at a methodic, yet consistent, pace, the human drama quickly amps up the tension.

The passenger’s first escape plan is quite possibly one of the most ingenious set pieces to ratchet up suspense in recent memory. McClean could have easily turned this sequence into a rip-roaring series of bloodletting, yet the director realizes the strength of letting the audiences’ imagination do the work. Not only is infinitely more nerve-racking for the viewer, but it cuts down on budgetary costs too. With much of the film shot on location on the Outback’s waterways, this was an incredibly smart move in the filmmaker’s part. Throw in a great homage to Jaws, and viewers will certainly be squirming in their seats for a fraction of the cost.

While the finale might have been a bit hokey on its own, by the time we have arrived at it, the viewer is left at whit’s end, making it a rousing conclusion. Thankfully, McClean also showed restraint with his two stars here. While it would have been easy to try and build the human emotion during the climax by showing a cheap romantic connection between Radha Mitchell and Michael Vartan, he avoids this cliché by having a relationship based off of mutual respect and only the slightest hint of something sexual. With well-rounded performances throughout, especially from the young Mia Wasikowska, the star of Tim Burton’s upcoming project, Alice in Wonderland, Rogue is truly terrifying.

reply

thanks two really good reviews!

reply

You're welcome GirlyfromOz.

http://www.moviehole.net/200814692-rogue-unrated-dvd

All in all, "Rogue" is a good little monster movie. Of course it isn't "Jaws," and throughout the film it's hard not to compare the two films, with Spielberg's shark always besting the hungry croc. If you're looking for an in-depth character piece, look elsewhere, because this movie's story isn't even as deep as the murky waters its creature inhabits. Mclean doesn't get weighed down with a heavy plot and lots of character development, in fact he wastes little time jumping right into the action. As far as giant killer crocodile movies go, don't waste your time on "Lake Placid 2," or "Primeval" - sink your teeth into Greg Mclean's "Rogue." It's definetly the best of the lot, and odds are you'll be pleasantly surprised.

reply

ROGUE may not be a masterpiece, nor does it set records for gut-level intensity, but McLean proves he can broaden his appeal beyond cult horror enthusiasts and gore hounds, delivering an enjoyable horror fright fest that is cathartic rather than traumatizing. It is altogether unfortunate that his film lost the race to beat PRIMEVAL into U.S. theatres; that rival killer croc’s quick box office death demoted ROGUE to virtual direct-to-video status (outside of a handful of play-dates, presumably to satisfying contractual obligations, ROGUE bypassed theatres in this country).

The injustice is that ROGUE is by far the better film; McLean sticks to a simple man-versus-nature theme and delivered the gory goods, unburdened by pretentious political posturing that marred the rival production. In the small sub-genre of aggressive alligator movies, 1980’s ALLIGATOR remains the best, thanks to its deft tongue-in-cheek humor and well-drawn characters, but ROGUE easily rips its way ahead of the rest of the pack.


Read the rest here: http://cinefantastiqueonline.com/2008/08/05/dvd-review-rogue-2008

reply

Thank you STEVE-1559 for the link to the full review of 'Rogue' plus the DVD extras. Each review has been really interesting to read.

reply

Thanks Wyatt2005 for these 3 great reviews.

reply