Maddie......as a judge.


Her judging critiques are sounding repetitive. Kind of dry. Why do I have a weird feeling if they continue this series, that they might replace Maddie ?

I am a Maddie fan...but not as a judge.

reply

I cringe whenever I hear her utter "you guys" and "soooo amazing." I know it's coming in every critique she gives. But she brings in the tween viewers who think she's God.

reply

Agreed.

reply

I'm not the biggest Maddie fan. There are other kids far better than her that are more deserving of the limelight she currently has. With that being said, she's just a kid. She's not even at the age for speech class. Sure she isn't an eloquent or intelligent speaker who understands the nuances of the English language, but that's not what she is there for. She's there to draw in people who have watched Dance Moms.

reply

She's almost 14, but she sounds like she's 11. Tate is much more well-spoken. Actually, all of the contestants seem better-spoken than Maddie.

reply

Jesus, JoJo Siwa would have been more interesting. Maddie sounds as if she knows nothing about dance.

reply

Maddie knows a lot of these choreographers personally and some of the dancers having worked with them in the past, she loves and supports their work,you can't expect her to be harsh on her good friends....Nigel and Paula are not active dancers or choreographers anymore so they can look at it more objectively

reply