MovieChat Forums > Shanghai Kiss (2007) Discussion > Just saw this movie. Just one Question!

Just saw this movie. Just one Question!


does anyone else find it odd that the character of Liam is supposed to be 28 and the character of Adelaide is only 16? I mean I liked the movie, but I just found the whole age difference a bit strange.

And no this isnt because he's a asian actor and shes a white actor. Or any of those dumb hollywood stereotypes. They could have had a 24 year old actress play Haydens 16 year old character and I would still be a bit freaked about it.

I just didnt get what the director was trying to convey with there relationship. I mean, if one of my friends was 28 and started somewhat "dating" and spending alot of time with a girl thats 16, I would slap the *beep* out of him.

reply

I guess that's the point. If Adelaide was closer in age, then he wouldn't be so conflicted and would've had no reason not to go out with her. Then he wouldn't have a reason to force himself into a relationship with someone his age (Micki). And his friend, Joe, did tease him all the time about spending a lot of time with a sixteen year old.

The age difference is odd, strange, and you're supposed to be freaked about it. Liam is freaked about it. That's why he's so confused.

Anyway, that's my take.

V


reply

Well, the idea that old guy dating young girl is odd, is odd itself. I like young girls when im 18, why should it change when im 50?

although i believe the point from the director is to trying to convey in the movie is that love knows no boundries. but still it is interesting to ask urself why do u think certain things are wrong? because ya mama tells u?

reply

well she played a 16 year old character in the film. Not a 18 year old.

and yeah, a 16 year old dating a 28 year old is wrong IMO.

Would you really want your 16 year old high school daughter dating a 28 year old or a 48 year old?

reply

well for the most part they were hanging out... he would never even kiss her on the lips...

before he moves to shanghai she is almost 17... a few weeks away...

more than a year passes...

so by the end of the movie she is 18...

reply

Add two years to the both of them, and suddenly it becomes legal, though they're still the same people. In the movie, it's her coming on to him, and him being really careful so it doesn't get out of hand. She's 17 when he admits to her (and himself) that he loves her, and then she leaves for Paris. She's over 18 when she returns, and they haven't even fooled around yet. She's been in Paris for a year, and when she gets back they still love each other. A lot of "adult" relationships wouldn't survive that much time apart.

Don't get me wrong, I support all the laws to protect minors against sexual predators, but it's not always that black and white. I think the movie handled it quite good.

I will admit that I don't have any children of my own, so perhaps it's easy for me to act all liberal and open-minded on this subject. When I was in highschool though, there were a couple of girls (under 18) dating guys 7, 8 years older, and that never seemed wrong to us. It was very clear who wore the pants in those relationships, and it wasn't the guy :D

EDIT: I'm from Belgium. Here, sexual contacts are legally allowed if you're 16 years old, or 14 if the partner is a minor also.

reply

its still legal to go to the cinema with a 16 year old when ya like 28...just dont get to bang the *beep* outta her :D

reply

I know you like to!! (so do I actually and it's legal here for 16+ ), but I'd never get involved. Teenagers are still teenagers.. pain in the behind!!!

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]