Nancy and Narissa were way hotter than Giselle

"I just appreciate beauty (not that it should really concern you)"

Then who should it concern and why are you posting it on a public message board?

"I never said she was more "objectively better looking"."

"Nancy was much cuter"
"Amy has plain features and is cute at best."

Those are objective statements. Whenever you post about Adams (which is seemingly a lot for no apparent reason) you are always making statements as though they are the objective truth rather than expressing that they are just your opinion.

"Why should it matter if women judge how women look? If they don't do it out of insecurity who gives a crap?"

Why should people be so judgemental anyway. I don't think men should be going around saying things like "such and such is a plain jane" etc. either, but at least that actually makes some sense- men are biologically conditioned to judge women in order to find their best mate (and vice versa). There is no apparent reason for people to insult and make nonconstructive criticisms of other peoples looks if they are of the same sex.

"Cuz it irritates me when people act like straight women, even non-jealous ones, aren't allowed to have any say in women are are or are not goodlooking."

It would not irritate me at all if you merely expressed your opinion that Idina is more attractive than Amy (I wouldn't see the point, which is why I asked you those questions, but whatever), that is if you didn't seem to feel the need to put Amy down constantly.
Note the fact that I used the word "complain" in my above post. That is what irritates me, not that you are expressing your differing opinion but that you do it in an unpleasant manner. That and the way you say everything as though it is objective truth.

"I wish more people like Idina were appreciated is all"

Is it your opinion that the beauty and talent of women like Idina and Susan Sarandon can only be appreciated if you put down other women (like Amy, Anne Hathaway, Zooey Deschanel etc.) because that is what it seems like.

"I think she is very overrated like many of the most popular actresses today."

People's overuse of the word overrated irritates me as well. I can understand that you would get annoyed by the rabid fans of the above actresses, if they were being rude/hostile/insulting to other people, but that doesn't mean you should sink to their level by being insulting back. Otherwise, why does it bother you that people like and appreciate things that you don't?

"Amy is only "very attractive" to you"

Clearly that is not true considering all of the adoration on this board and in outside reviews and articles. I'm assuming her fiance finds her attractive as well.

"if you think she is somehow objectively better looking than Idina you simply don't have a leg to stand on."

That is absolutely not what I meant, seeing as beauty is obviously always subjective (although seemingly not to you, considering the way that you write). I do think, however, that if you were trying to make an objective argument (which I don't think you should and I only brought up because of the way you were talking about them) for who is better looking based on how many people and by what degree those people are attracted to each person, you would have a better leg to stand on if you were arguing for Amy Adams considering not only general public opinion but also studies done on peoples perceptions of facial structure and facial symmetry (which is why I mentioned Idina's nose and jaw).

"how is any of that relevent to my opinion that Nancy and Narissa (who I must admit you ignored during your lecture) are betterlooking than the one most people find prettier?"

It is relevant in the sense that you are being unnecessarily harsh about someone who, by all evidence, does not deserve it.


I may lecture, but only in the, probably vain, hope that people on these boards, and in general, would be less unnecessarily harsh about other people.

Agreed, on both.

Not to mention they both tend to make their characters overact IMO, like in the third Spiderman... she made MJ sound psycho about him talking to Gwen. And as for Amy, she's just not princess material. Too nerdy, if you ask me.

Where have all the graveyards gone? Covered with flowers every one