MovieChat Forums > Supernatural (2005) Discussion > Alternate Charlie

Alternate Charlie

posted 7 years ago by SammiWin (1112)
3 replies | jump to latest

Wouldn't she be way different? And wasn't Charlie not even her real name? I just thought in the Alternate world she would've been a completely different person.

[–] DiToA (50) 7 years ago

I'm gonna say no, only to her character in particular. The angels in the AU AND the Leviathan in our world both know she's not like most humans, but she's not exactly a big bad. I kind of expect her character to remain the same regardless of what universe she's in only because there's something a little bit different about her. Of course, if they would expand on her character a little bit more, we might know more about why she is the way she is.

[–] Bella-UK (1288) 7 years ago

This isn't the old Charlie we know not by a long shot, and I think it will be interesting to see what the actress does with her to change the new 'Charlie'. I felt she dumbed her original character to this one down a lot. Which makes her more bearable. She needs to be different to be a character in the AU like we've seen with Michael and Zachariah even Bobby and Kevin. Sometimes not for the better, but Charlie does appear different, very much so. The NEW Charlie is more determined to help and see a job through. She wants to be apart of the mission and the pack. She doesn't appear to be that frightened when you think what torture she appears to have been through by the angels. So far, she's not doing a bad job.

[–] fishpan (544) 7 years ago

Apparently not and after the last episode am back to really disliking her as my hopes of toning her down has gone out the window.

She is sparkly awesome in the face of regular torture. But yet they don't really show me her being tortured to give me an idea that she is really sparkly awesome. Then they have Ketch, the hardened professional (even though he's on a redemption kick) goes through with Charlie's stupid plan and walks straight into being captured? Then he breaks inside when he sees her being head screwed by AU Cas. How many people has he seen tortured? Suddenly Charlie is the line where torture is too far?

Sorry am now at the point where I wouldn't be surprised if there is a line that announces that every version of Charlie poops sparkle glitter ice cream.