42 took a lot of liberties and omits a bunch of key people.
For example, in the film Jackie reaches first, then steals 2nd ... then 3rd ... then home! The real Robinson's first Major League at-bat was a ground-out to 3rd, his second was a fly-out to Left, and his third he hit into a double-play. He ended his debut by reaching on error during a sacrifice. They later claim he has stolen 27 bases without being caught (which in reality, he had been thrown out 11 times), and so forth.
They even get the small details, like the Dodgers' radio station, wrong! (WHN, not WMGM)
Jackie's performances in the film are pretty much entirely fictional, he received tremendous support from his team-mates, and two other teams had black players within about 2 months of his debut. He had a damn tough job, and he did it with a remarkable amount of class.
To be honest, this film is kind of insulting what the REAL man did by over dramatizing in comic book fashion what actually happened. His REAL fears, such as that none of his teammates would even shake his hand in public when he did well, much less actually support him, and that he played through them with a steel mask on his face. The REAL comportment and class he showed, even when he felt he was wronged.
It's also pretty damn insulting to many players that showed no evidence of being racist, and treated Jackie just like they treated everybody else ... like Enos Slaughter. Yeah, he spiked him. He also spiked Rigney, and plenty of other people (all white). It was his style.
As Entertainment, judge it how you will. As History, it is pretty *&#@(!@ terrible.
reply
share