Everyone the critic said he needed was correct. he never said who should be who. It was Heap who made the mistake of deciding which person fit the role.
sharebut critic had bad attitude so had to die
http://www.kindleflippages.com/ablog/
Very true. It's not like he was wrong per say. I mean the people he assumed were there to help fit the descriptions. Of course one of the main issues is Story thinking he was the protector when he was actually the healer, that shifts some things around.
shareAlthough, the critic failed to mention the two witnesses: "the man who has no secrets and one whose opinion is highly respected" so technically, his response was right but incomplete.
share