This movie is not for animal lovers
Geez. The dog, the horses. It was pretty brutal.
shareWhat about the pig in the begining of the movie? Or 'animal lovers' care only for dogs' welfare?
sharefor real! exactly what i thought when i watched it for the forst time today! ohh gosh poor animals! eh
i care, so don't do it
Yeah and what about the humans? Any human lovers out there that would have trouble seeing humans get slaughtered left and right for 80s years?
---
Gimme a break. There's always someone who takes issue with people who care about animals and don't want to see them tortured and killed in movies. Immediately, we are labeled as anti-human, which is so far from the truth.
Lest any of us forget, let me remind you: Humans are the primary reason this world is so *beep* up in the first place, and we globally continue to do our very best every day to destroy this planet -- and ALL its precious life forms -- in countless, devastating, and irreversible ways.
[deleted]
Nope, the humans here caused it all in the first place - dur
shareWell, the point is that humans don't really get killed in films because they're just pretending. Animals do sometimes really get killed films, without pretending. That's the difference.
shareWhy are so many people upset about the pig?! Doesn't ANYONE like bacon? YES it was slaughtered...how do you think you get pork?? You just walk it past a fire and then eat it alive?
And, for Christ's sake, it's a movie! The animals weren't ACTUALLY killed.
Sheesh...
Oder: Wie ich aufhören, sich Sorgen und Liebe die Bombe gelernt!
YES SOME PEOPLE DO NOT LIKE BEACON FOR THE SIMPLE REASON THAT IT IS AN ANIMAL WHO WAS KILLED FOR YOUR STUPID SELFISH SPECIST STOMACH.
Some people are VEGAN, and for very good reasons.
But ah, the pleasure of bacon compared to the horrific lives and deaths of billions of animals.....GEt your head out of your ass and watch the truth.
"MEET YOUR MEAT" is a good start.
Good luck to you.
Latest research shows that our far-distant ancestors only made the leap to true human consciousness when they started eating meat. Would our vegan friends have kept us as a sort of lovable, dumb, grazing ape-people for all the millennia of our history? Actually, the way they go on, I think they would! But at least we wouldn't have to endure holier-than-thou comments like this.
shareLove animals, always have. I was even an animal welfare activist for a long time. I still enjoy this film and understand that it is FICTION. What I don't understand is why these threads have to turn into name-calling and vegetarian v. omnivore preaching.
Everybody chill, it's just a movie. And no animals were really harmed.
agreed. I know no animals were REALLY harmed, but it's still brutal...
"The dreams of youth are the regrets of maturity"
Animal lovers should watch Cujo instead. That dog gets a lot of good meals. Or Jaws; that's one well-fed shark, and I'm pretty sure it never realizes what happens when it's finally put down quite humanely by officer Brody.
shareThe death of the dog I expected, considering he was trying to kill Victor. The horses seemed part of the curse too.
Your post is great.
If we can save humanity, we become the caretakers of the world
I'm an animal lover (the sensitive, activist type) and the whole reason I looked this movie up is because I saw a gif on Tumblr of a gory-looking horse. I thought it might look cool, and maybe if I'm lucky, be a most excellent animatronic puppet or somesuch.
Fake is fake, and as long as it's not too realistic and seemingly cruel, I don't really see how I would have a problem with it myself. However, everyone is different, of course.
How brutal are we talking about here? I mean, I refuse to watch Bambi again, because the movie focuses on how sad and messed up Bambi's mother being shot and him being alone as a baby is. But I'm probably being a baby about it, because I remember that a bunch of other cute stuff happened in the movie too.
I've seen Nekromantic, which has an actual rabbit killing and skinning (filmed at a farm where it was going to be killed either way) at the beginning and end of it (backwards at the end). I did not like that at all.
There is also a (fake) cat scene, in which, after he kills the cat by bashing it in a bag, right after feeding and petting it (which bothered me a lot, because the cat being fed and pet was real, which I'm sure was the point); he cuts it up and bathes with parts of it, rubbing it on his body. Not really my favourite thing. :/
But like, in Cloud Atlas, a dog gets shot off-screen, pretty quickly, so I wouldn't call something like that brutal by comparison to other things I've seen. I don't like it, but it's moved past pretty quickly and goes on to something else.
However, in Sympathy for Lady Vengeance, even though she shoots the puppy off-screen, because of the way they make a big deal about it, in the way that it's directed/shot, it was pretty disturbing. Also, it's not like it was attacking or barking or anything. She just brought it to kill it; to desensitize herself.
I get that it's sometimes necessary to portray a character being cruel to an animal, to show that they are cruel/lack empathy; for instance, in Splice, when Dren kills her cat, to show that she as becoming aggressive, homicidal and so on. That was difficult to sit through; I guess because it was pretty realistic and Dren was being cruel. It was also a bit overlong for that kind of thing. (Plus, I'm a cat person on top of being an animal person in general.)
Basically, what I'm getting at, is that it's how it's portrayed that gets to me. If we're talking like possessed/zombie animals that are attacking a character, who then kills them, well that just makes sense, but if they are killing them for fun or something, or it's really focused on, then it would bother me. It also matters how long it is seen and how much is shown. I wouldn't want to watch a movie if a lot of the movie was about killing animals, even if they were just zombies or something.
Companion animals, like cats, dogs, horses, etc, seem to be difficult for most people to see die in a movie. I don't even like to see a fake spider get squashed though. It's silly, but I'm just a really nice person who loves animals (and humans, who are also animals) and tries to let myself get completely caught up in a movie. I'll still sit through a lot of things anyway, but I do often look away from stuff like that.
Interesting to think about. I wonder how other people feel about it; like if it's more psychological (like it seems to be for me), or if it's more visual or what.