MovieChat Forums > Knowing (2009) Discussion > Not just two white kids

Not just two white kids


I keep seeing threads about the racist nature of this film. People questioning why the movie ends with two white kids left to repopulate an entire planet. Didn't you guys watch the entire movie? Dozens alien ships (perhaps more) were seen leaving earth and landing on the other planet. They saved more children than just those two particular ones we saw in the movie.


I looked into the TARDIS and the TARDIS looked into me.

reply

[deleted]

I'm always surprised and offended by stupidity. In fact, I'm surprised and offended by the stupidity of my own typos in my previous post. :D

Also, I didn't realize IMDB had an ignore button. Good to know.

I looked into the TARDIS and the TARDIS looked into me.

reply

It's almost certain they only saved the two white kids, because they're trying to depict the "new start" as Adam and Eve, and they were headed for the Tree of Knowledge (forbidden fruit) in the end.

Perhaps the mass ships were like Noah's Arc... They kids did bring two rabbits as well.

reply

I seriously doubt that...and stop acting like a racist, seriously.

reply

also ignore my last message.....aparently i went brain dead and didnt read your message correctly. My apologies.

reply

ethSin that's actually a really good point. However, while I agree that their intention was to depict "a new start" for humanity, I highly doubt that they were asking us to believe that these two particular kids not only represent the diversity of humanity but are also responsible for the continuation of an entire species. My personal opinion is that the other ships we see are each carrying two children.

I looked into the TARDIS and the TARDIS looked into me.

reply

I really believe that story.
of course, all the other ships contains a lot of animals, to create a new world.

And the rascist thing is ridiculous! Of course the aliens could save 2 black kids too, and then what? Also save 2 black horses? 2 black rabbits? (I noticied the rabbits where white). etc etc.
I am sure evolution and circumstances will make enough colour differations in a few millions of years.

Marius

reply

At this time of being politically correct, it would have been nice to see pairs of kids of diverse races; but the director maybe did not want his final shot to look like a Benetton ad.

reply

well... but there are more as 2 flavours in the world, don't you think?
We have white, black, brown, yellow, and redskin in the world.
So, lets forget that politically correctiness, shall we? ;-)

I like the Adam and Eve scene more, and in fact, the 2 kids should be both black. Because didnt humanity not started in Ethiopie? According to the latest science?

Marius

reply

Hopefully they were all white too

reply

When the spaceship lifted off, we see it join a bunch of other similar spaceships leaving from other parts of the earth so I assumed that many other children of different races and nationalities were taken as well.

reply

Two people cannot repopulate a race.
Inbreeding and genetic deformities are a thing.

reply

Two people cannot repopulate a race. Inbreeding and genetic deformities are a thing.


Actually, no they're not. At least not to the extent that people think they are. Sure, our genetic diversity would be an issue for the first few generations, but, in fact, the first generation of offspring only have a 4% chance of problems arising. Put that in contrast to the general populations 2% chance. Not really all that bad, when you consider it. Also, early humans were constantly inbreeding, and we seem to have managed rather well.

Violence. If its not solving all your problems, youre simply not using enough.
-Zaraki Kenpachi

reply

The selection of two white kids would be the right choice. If they are going to re-populate the earth there would be no point in taking Africans or Asians. Better genetic material is needed. It would have been racist and fundamentally unsound to have had Asian or African kids selected.

reply

Asians are typically very intelligent and hard working, they would be a great asset to a new start.

African kids provide great....

Okay African kids are not necessary.

reply

*beep* like this is why they're taking the boards away.

Never been a gangsta but I play hardball.

reply

Wow..

I can't believe the racist comments. But what's even more hypocritical are the racists themselves. Can't tell you how many times, how they "don't like minorities" - and i'll use the term loosely..

Yet.. when they see a pretty/beautiful one? They pursue that woman like they never heard of "Dave Duke".. Trust me.. I'm a product of that, and millions of others, through absolute love or plain old rape. My dad was a grand wizard of the KKK. He, like many of the Klansmen, "forgot" about racism, when they laid eyes on beauty, resilience and strength, that a white female snowflake will never have.

And let's not talk about those lily white females who conveniently overlook the white guys - but can't grab a black man from the night club fast enough..

Such hypocrites..

reply

It's still THE best plane crash ever put on celluloid.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E6gWFTv3xE8

reply

There were hundreds of ships leaving Earth at the end of the movie. Are we to believe that each ship only carried one white boy and one white little girl? Are we to believe that ALL the saved humans were kids? The kid from the beginning grew up and knew where to be picked up, but she died. Also, the alien puts the sentence in the boy's mind, only the ones that heard the message can go. Does that mean only kids and/or adults? I would think there is way more diversity than what people picked up on. In my opinion, there are plenty of clues that say thousands of humans of all walks were saved by the aliens.

reply