MovieChat Forums > Scott Pilgrim vs. the World (2010) Discussion > The best adaptation of a "graphic novel"...

The best adaptation of a "graphic novel" ever


It's fresh, funny, audacious, witty and well written, and has a kickin' score. In short, It ROCKS big time! I LOVED it! I think I'll even buy the CD.

Schrodinger's cat walks into a bar, or doesn't.

reply

Inclined to disagree with the title, but I did enjoy the movie a lot. Lucas Lee was my favorite EX tbh lol.

reply

Agreed. Not best adaptation (they missed a LOT of character development; there just wasn't time in the film) but an enjoyable film. 6/10.

Graphic novels:
Vol 1,2 = 9/10
vol. 3-5 = 10/10
vol 6 = 6/10

reply

What about 'Watchmen'?

reply

Watchmen seemed to compromise too much. Not to mention Watchmen's source material is so deep & rich, SP wins by a bit of default.

Sin City is in the mix also, though it has not aged well at all.

...top 50 http://www.imdb.com/list/ls056413299/

reply

[deleted]

Dude whaaaat? Sin city is still visually so stunning

reply

MTV Oddities: the Maxx

imo

reply