MovieChat Forums > Paradise Now (2005) Discussion > What happended to Khaled?

What happended to Khaled?


Is it likely that the people would kill Khaled because he failed to carry out the plan and see him as a "collaborator"? So is he a dead man either way?


"Goats and monkeys!"-Othello, Act IV,Scene 1

reply

No, as Said's father was the example of a collaborator - he had betrayed the Palestinian cause in the eyes of the militants and had collaborated with the Israelis. It's unlikely he'd be killed because he got cold feet or was not brave enough.

reply


Change the F$%&g name of your thread please!! it revales part of the end in the damn subject.

www.myspace.com/diablosangeleseinsectos

reply

You don't have to be rude, friend.

"Goats and monkeys!"-Othello, Act IV,Scene 1

reply

It seems unlikely the organisation would take action against Khaled. Saïd alone would do enough damage for them to be satsified with the whole thing.

But the emotional impact on Khaled would be big enough (guilt for his friend, questions about his own courage / dedication to the Palestinian cause / ...)

-------------------

Also, I wonder, at what point did Khaled change his mind ? At the start of the film he was all for it, whereas Saïd seemed hesitant. Yet, at the end, they both changed there minds (Khaled not going through with it and Saïd being very determined).

Saïd clearly has his "moment of insight" during the talk with that leader dude (Abu something) he talked about how he blames Israel not only for killing "active" Palestinians, but also for driving others (like his father) to collaboration (the ultimate humiliation in his view). So what similar moment did Khaled have ?

I am not a complete idiot. Some parts are missing.

reply

the ride in the car with the woman, when she explained that it won't help to kill themselves

reply

Not just Suha's drive - when he was driving throughout the area looking for Said.

Now I know that Nablus is an underdeveloped and bombed out shell, but during the sequence when Khaled is looking for Said, he is, for perhaps the first time in his life, looking at the environment he lives in.

Not the poverty and rubble, but the hum of life - the hustle and bustle of people flowing in and out of stores and up and down the market streets. All the people in cars driving forward, all the vendours with their colourful products and foods lit by sunlight on display, all the women with their distinct wraps and scarves, all the children running down the sidewalks, the thick blinding plumes of brown dust from the road, the sunlight dappling everything.

Just as Said, early in the film, finds solace in breathing in the nighttime panorama of Nablus, Khaled soaks in the world he was raised in, sees it alive.

That was the beginning of his transformation.

His exchange with Suha continued the transformation, and his ironic relief at finding Said still alive, and his ironic desire to keep Said alive, cements his transformation.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Excellent insight, thanks! I too kept wondering about Said's nihilism. As bad as things were portrayed, there seemed reason for hope and life too. The lovely woman who seemed so interested in him and so full of spirit. The job he had, and the lovely caring family. So much to live for, yet he was blinded by religion and by the shame that was imposed upon his family for his father's so-called weakness.

reply

TemporaryOne-1, that's an excellent post. Great way of describing it.

Voting Democrat over Republican is like asking your rapist to use a condom.

reply

Silly question. Do you think Hamas have severance pay?

reply

Maybe not. But the important question is: do they have bereavement leave? And if the death occurs outside of the borders, is there an additional 2 days travel time granted?

reply

Hamas has long since ceased the practice of suicide bombing.

Voting Democrat over Republican is like asking your rapist to use a condom.

reply