MovieChat Forums > Odd Girl Out (2005) Discussion > Who was more evil Nikki or Stacy?

Who was more evil Nikki or Stacy?

posted 12 years ago by starfairy326
11 replies | jump to latest

I thought Nikki was extremely evil up to the point where she doesn't have a soul or the decency to stop the bullying when Vanessa was sent to the emergency room from the drug overdosage.

Stacy was cruel as well where I thought it was pathetic for her to care more about being popular and becoming friends with the mean kids. I loved how Vanessa confronted in the end and told her off about her behaviors. If Vanessa and Stacy were ever "best friends" Stacy would have never treated Vanessa like that to become friends with Nikki and believed all the rumors being spread.

[–] juicebox07 12 years ago

Stacy was a horrible friend. That's certain. However, I think Nikki was more evil in this case, and I wish Vanessa had told her off too. She was the one who started/instigated the bullying. Same with Tiffany. I thought those two did more than Stacy did. Nikki was supposed to be Vanessa's friend too. Maybe they weren't as tight but still.

[–] starfairy326 12 years ago

I understand Stacy liked Tony and she was upset because she actually believe in the rumors that Vanessa accepted to go on a date with Stacy's crush. I thought it wasn't fair that Stacy didn't get the chance to hear Vanessa's side of the story on what really happened in the hallway.

[–] Catnip86 12 years ago

My vote would be Stacy. After the bullying started, the others never pretended to be Vanessa's friend the way Stacy did. Stacy could have stood up for her "best friend" but chose not to. And she gave the clique the fuel they needed to torment Vanessa.

[–] echosmomma 11 years ago

Completely agree...Stacey was so two-faced, making her the most evil, in my opinion.

[–] shoshonehuey 11 years ago

Stacey....because she was a wolf in sheep's clothing. Nikki was just a plain wolf, I don't think Vanessa was ever close to her to begin with.

Angelina Jolie. Liz Taylor. Bette Davis. Charlize Theron. Mae West.

[–] SydLorraine 11 years ago

Both had certain levels of evil. Nikki was straight up evil. She didn't care one way or another who she hurt. Stacy was weak. She was popular and would do anything to stay that way. But deep down she knew it was wrong to be treating Vanessa that way. Unfortunately, the desire to be popular and be "one of the gang" overrode everything. As for Tiffany, she was just someone Nikki grabbed to jump on the Vanessa-hate bandwagon because she was a wannabe. Nikki would have recruited anyone.

[–] Ashley868 11 years ago

Stacy was more evil. Like Vanessa said, everyone knew what to expect from Nikki. Stacy pretended to still be friends Vanessa to her face, but behind her back she was a bitch. Nikki and the other girls were definitely bitches, but at least they were honest about their opinions. Stacy wasn't at all, she would have jumped on the bandwagon no matter who it was. If it had been Vanessa bullying Nikki or Tiffany, Stacy would have bullied them. I think that's worse.

[–] honeybee1982 11 years ago

i'll admit nikki and tiffany were bitches but the queen of bitches award would have to go to stacy cuz she was supposed to be her best friend and was the fakest of all too, i would have never guessed that they were best friends if they never said it, i don't think anyone would have ever known

[–] EarthPrincess82 11 years ago

Yeah I couldn't agree more! Stacy was more evil because she was extremely manipulative when she was called out and always tried to con her way out of the situation. She started the whole thing! Nikki was never really Vanessa's "friend" to begin with. She was just Stacy's pathetic little sidekick and so was Tiffany. They would've never bullied Vanessa had it not been for Stacy.

[–] 11 years ago

[deleted]

[–] crazyforyou19 10 years ago

LOL yesss i agree, her eyes were like my gosh is she going to stab vanessa because she looks like she would at the snap of a finger