Why did the lady in the beginning get so pummeled?
I understand that she was hovering toward the box with a ball peen hammer, and that the box was probably protecting itself. But why? We find out later in the film that this "spirit/demon" goes after children. So why the older lady? One could argue that the demon figures "better an adult lady than nothing at all", and it was restated that this demon could possess adults, as it did to daddy at the end. But it's also established that when a person is being controlled or "possessed" by the demon that their eyes roll back and become all milky. So the demon definitely has influence over this woman. Let's fast forward to later when the daughter is possessed. She acts as a protector to the box. She doesn't want dad going anywhere near it and strives to ensure it's safekeeping. I suppose my question is this: If the woman in the beginning was possessed by the spirit, then why would it even be trying to destroy the box at all? Wouldn't she want to protect the box and be obsessive about it too? If she wasn't possessed by the demon in the first place until the moment it took her over body, then why would she want to destroy the box. How did she know it was evil? Maybe you could chalk it up to "mystery", but just maybe. If the woman was supposed to have been possessed by the demon the whole time, her actions run contrary to what we see later with the girl. It just clouds the plot unnecessarily.
You could explain yourself better by not burying the lead and by not confusing two questions.
The woman was only possessed long enough to harm herself. It wasn't like with the child, where the spirit was trying to re-enter the world. The woman wasn't possessed prior, and would have zero compulsion to protect the box.
Rewatching the scene with the teacher. Same deal.
Movies are IQ tests; the IMDB boards are how people broadcast their score.
I do wonder who was the one that gave the old woman the box since I thought she died considering how she was attacked when attempting to destroy the box but survived.
Wasn't the box supposed to be the demon's prison? Wouldn't destroying the box free the demon? This is the biggest part of the movie that just doesn't make any sense.
I could be wrong, but it was my understanding that while the box did contain/ imprison the demon, it was also what kept it here in this world. I thought I understood that without the box or a person (particularly a child) to possess, it wouldn't be able to stay here. I think the original case (if you beleive in such things) revolved around a demon being called forth via a ouija board and attempting to possess someone. It wasn't able to hold on and faded out again. They did another ouija session, this time with a dybbuk box present in an attempt to catch the demon and trap it.
So, while it can't possess anyone while the box is sealed, it can cause things to happen and protect itself.
As to the old lady having the box in the first place: Again, in the original story, I think that the woman who has possession of the box (and sold it at a yard sale) said she got it from her mother and that it had been passed down via her great great grandmother or something like that, perhaps even one of the original women who trapped the demon during the spiritualism craze of the late 1900's. In the original story, the woman who sold it at a yard sale was selling of the possessions of her deceased mother or aunt or something. The man who purchased it was an antiques and second hand dealer. He brought it to his store and things started happening, etc. He pried the box open and found an odd assortment of old things, including some fabric, cotton balls and some teeth. Shortly afterward, he claims his stock room was destroyed while one of his employees hunkered down in terror. At one point (according to the man and his mother), his mother fell into a coma-like trance while staring at the box. She apparently stayed that way for hours, and finally came to awhile after the box was removed from her sight. He ended up selling it to someone online. That person became obsessed with the box, even began sleeping with it. He and his roommates began having all sorts of problems~ illnesses, "supernatural" activities, items in their house being thrown and destroyed. It went to someone else after that (not sure how it was passed, it has been a long time since I read the story). He had a bad feeling about the box and I don't believe he opened it. That person started to experience problems and he is the one who began to research the box and its history. He found a rabbi who helped him determine what to do with the box to keep it safe and keep people safe from it. The current owner supposedly has the box stashed somewhere "safe" and untouchable. He has refused to allow anyone to see it or to tell anyone where it is located. Supposedly, only he and the rabbi know. He said that the paranormal instances in his life have ceased, but he is haunted by the problem of what to do with the box after he passes, to make sure it stays safe and away from people.
"Wasn't the box supposed to be the demon's prison? Wouldn't destroying the box free the demon? This is the biggest part of the movie that just doesn't make any sense."
For God's sake ... the woman doesn't know what the audience (later) discovers about the nature of these boxes. The box terrifies her, so - naturally - she attempts to destroy it.