MovieChat Forums > Alpha Dog (2007) Discussion > He basically killed his own brother

He basically killed his own brother


Not only did the things he did cause his little brother to be put in danger, but that phone call, had he kept his cool, would've gone a whole different way. They would've sent his brother home if Jake didn't threaten to snatch Truelove's life..

reply

When he knew who took him why didn't he call the police?

reply

Criminals don't usually have good credibility with the police.

reply

Killing him was STUPID. There is not a chance in hell they would have gotten fifty years for kidnapping. If I was the judge I would let them plea bargain their way down to contributing to the delinquency of a minor and then I would have given them some probation time and maybe a hundred hours of community service each then after they served their probation and did their community service I would allow them to have it expunged from their records so that they would not need to list it on a job interview.

Why commit CAPITAL MURDER when you would only be facing PROBATION???

They were really THAT STUPID??

reply

These were not first timers, confused kids caught in the wrong place at the wrong time, they were hardened criminals, all of them. They were not strangers to drug dealing, assault, robbery, weapons, etc. If they got pinched for the kidnapping, they were definitely doing jail.

reply

@creatorof2002

You're just assuming they'd receive probation for kidnaping, when in reality they would be charged with life, as said by Trueloves lawyer. They could've bargained a deal and gotten a reduced sentence I'm sure, but Johnny was a stubborn, not so intelligent individual who took his chance with murder. Clearly a big mistake as he received life imprisonment anyway.

reply

the movie portrayed it that way yes as movies tend to do, but in real life Jake had no idea Hollywood aka Truelove had anything to do with his brothers murder until after the body was found a couple days later.

He never made any threatening phone call to him.

" Tell me mom...when your little girl's on the slab...where will it tickle you?"

reply