MovieChat Forums > The Poseidon Adventure (2005) Discussion > TV vs Big Screen

TV vs Big Screen

posted 19 years ago by valandearl19
8 replies | jump to latest

Which one would you rather see. I would rather see the big screen one personally.

[–] 19 years ago

[deleted]

[–] gpreston01 19 years ago

Without a doubt the big screen version will be VASTLY superior to the one made by hallmark. Can't wait until May '06.

[–] 19 years ago

[deleted]

[–] bugchicklv1 19 years ago

TV Movie.

But only because Adam Baldwin is playing Mike.

[–] boofhead97 19 years ago

Your kidding right?

[–] beau88 19 years ago

I hope he is, i would rather Big Screen. Telemovie is cheesy (am watching it now)

[–] lawofthebicycle 19 years ago

After watching the TV movie, I wouldn't even bother with the big screen version.

If you check the reviews of the original, there are a few insightful comments that basically acknowledge that it did help to start a whole new wave of disaster movies in the '70's, and it certainly had it's positive points. But really, the case for a remake - even a good remake - seems very weak.

[–] earth_angel666 19 years ago

no, i wouldnt. because i doubt it would have the range of actors if it was made for the big screen