This is the WORST movie of 2008.....easily
First off, the premise is absolutely ridiculous. A psychologist who has a personal bias towards rape/murder suspects would never ever ever be a credible expert in a murder trial. Any defense attorney, even a crappy one, would be able to poke holes in their testimony by establishing his bias and immediately discrediting him. This whole thing is so stupid. Even the bad guy is lame, nothing creepy or ingeniuos about his plan, that stupid repeating of "tick tock doc" stuck with me like a case of diarhea.
Secondly, the script and acting is ATROCIOUS. Both Alicia Witt and Lelei Sobieski (sp?) are so god-awfully talentless that I actually feel bad for them. Al Pacino hasn't been a good actor in over 20 years and this movie just doesn't lend itself to alleged "star power."
Terrible plot, terribly un-suspenseful, terribly acted, terribly paced, yeah, there is nothing redeeming about this story.
If you like this movie, I actually pity you. Yeah yeah everyone is entitled to their opinion, but anyone who likes this movie obviously doesn't know what a "good movie" is. Sorry.