MovieChat Forums > A Scanner Darkly (2006) Discussion > Wouldn't of this been better if it was j...

Wouldn't of this been better if it was just a Comedy


I own this movie on blu-ray and love getting high to it but honestly the emotional dramatic parts with Arctor make this movie drag. If this was just a comedy I think this would of turned out much better. Honestly I could care less about the Substance D aspect to it. I just want to see these guys have fun, get f'ed up and be silly. I don't need all the drama.....bleck...gets depressing.

reply

The problem here is that it's not meant to be watched high. It's about the destruction that drugs can cause. You're looking for a completely different movie.

reply

Well, the book is anti prescription grade speed, which Philip K. Dick suffered the majority of his adult life addicted to. Without that addiction, there is a very good chance that his schizophrenia could have remained latent.

Of course, on the pro drugs side, he never would have created the ethereal work without that addiction. Both arguments have their place, but you really aren't presenting an argument to the man's work, you're ignoring the message of a fictionalized account of the man's life and knocking points off him for trying to create a thing of beauty and save people instead of creating a comedy pot heads can get high to. And I say that as a pot head. Don't make us look bad. Go out and write the novel or screenplay you want to see.

I've never been to prison for arson, but my musical ability will burn your house down.

reply

Drugs/mental illness in artists push them to the limit. They might be even better without them, but I think those effect mind very much and makes them what they are/were.

reply

And there is a very big difference between an artist who abuses drugs and a normal person who abuses drugs.

I've never been to prison for arson, but my musical ability will burn your house down.

reply