Which one would you date?
Which of the four girls would you date? I'd choose Carmen: She's the most mature and level-headed of the four, while having a strong sense of passion and assertiveness. Lena would be a close second for similar reasons. Bridget is too "wild" and unpredictable. Tibby doesn't seem emotionally available or open.
I've only seen the movies, so I'm sure I'm ignorant about more subtle personality traits revealed in the books.