MovieChat Forums > The Ice Harvest (2005) Discussion > Charlie's question to Renatta?

Charlie's question to Renatta?


"Where do you come from, originally?"

Why did he ask her that?

reply

That's a great question. And I'd love to know the answer.
When I was watching the movie, I was asking myself that same questions.
Initially I thought he was trying to figure out where she was going to run to with the money (so he could track her down if necessary).
But seeing as he was planning to shoot her and keep the money himself, I have no idea why he was asking her that!

reply

1) He's tired, demoralized, kind of knows what he has to do (knowing how and where she will end, he wonders where did she begin?). Its also sort of a "who the heck are you really???" kind of question, in context.

2) It might be left over from the book. In the book, Charlie's interior monologue shows how curious he is about where she is from. The book makes it clearer that she's from somewhere in (probably) Eastern Europe. She reads novels in a language Charlie doesn't recognize, has a thicker accent than in the film, etc.

reply

i thought he asked the question because he saw the bag of money, the bag vic had, in her closet. up until then charlie never knew vic and her were in on it.

i figured he asked because he knew where vic was from because they were close and just wanted to hear her say the same place to make sure he was right.

instead, he waited to feel the razor on his neck, then he shot her, because then he knew she was in on it with vic.

reply

i actually know this, i think
i read the book and the book talks about renata and her origins more in depth so i think that line was trying to make a reference to the book; there's a lot of lines like that, where teh movie mentions something that is talked a lot in teh book

reply

Why did Charles Foster Kane say "Rosebud" right before dying?

reply

Because it was the name of his sled, the thing he left behind when his parents gave him away. An event which probably marked his whole life, formed his desperate need to be loved, and left him somewhat maimed. "Rosebud" was the silent cry, the old longing for home of the forsaken child in him.

there's a highway that is curling up like smoke above her shoulder

reply

Who is John Galt?

reply

There's no mystery about that when you get further in Atlas Shrugged.

"Extremism in the pursuit of moderation is no vice."

reply