MovieChat Forums > Catch and Release (2007) Discussion > Just a thought.

Just a thought.

posted 17 years ago by stellarcode
4 replies | jump to latest

I loooove this movie, don't get me wrong.

But every time I watch a movie, I always imagine someone else playing the role. You know, who could've also suited it.

And I think Jennifer Garner was great. Although I'm not too fond of her.

But.

I really think Jennifer Aniston could have brought the same humble approach to the character, as well as the subtle and funny approach to the character, as well.

I don't know...but I feel Jennifer Aniston could have pulled it off better.

That and her and Timothy Olyphant(Fritz)would make a hot couple. lol.

Just my thoughts.

Who else do you all think could have played the role of Gray?

[–] lin-angel85 17 years ago

i dont think jennifer aniston would have done well at all. she doesn't have jennifer garner's soft, woundedness...if anyone saw juno as well as this movie, they'd know that she is best in roles where she is dealing with some type of pain -- being the wannabe mother in juno who so desperately wants a child, it was heartbreaking and so real, and she does the same thing in this -- the hurt, tortured widow who finds herself and her true love through a terrible experience. jennifer aniston has never done anything that makes me think she can pull of this type of emotion and sincerity. PLUS a big part of the movie was how well gray and fritz meshed...i just don't see aniston as being able to pull of the reality of that ....she always seems so fake in any role other than rachel green.

[–] 17 years ago

[deleted]

[–] ally_d25 17 years ago

I agree with JadeJustice agreeing with lin-ange

[–] stellarcode 17 years ago

Ok, cool.

I just wanted to see other people's opinions.

It's just a habit of mine when I watch movies, lol.