MovieChat Forums > The Perfect Man (2005) Discussion > This or A Cinderella Story?

This or A Cinderella Story?


Which do you prefer?

**"Be the rainbow in the storms of life." --Lord Byron**

reply

cinderella story i liked it the most what about you?

reply

Yeah, i agree with you on that one

**"Be the rainbow in the storms of life." --Lord Byron**

reply

Hmm I totally do not agree! I liked this one sooo much better... It's perfect ;)

reply

A Cinderella Story

reply

Do you even have to ask?! OF COURSE CINDY STORY!

Esteban Julio Rocundo Montuyo Del Rossa Ramirez!...or as will know be known as- "El Diablo".

reply

I liked them both

reply

Cinderella Story was better, but hilary's hair was better in this one :p

"Greatness inspires envy, envy engenders spite, spite spawns lies."

reply

A Cinderella Story, definitely.

You can tell him I didn't like the jelly so I went home to get some jam

reply

You're kidding right?

The Perfect Man wins by a landslide!

reply

I agree.

The cinderella one was a tad on the cheesie side!!

reply

A Cinderella Story was better but
I liked the Perfect Man but i didn't
really like the ending.

reply

Neither? Is that an option?

reply

Neither.
This movie sucked, at least for me. I do respect whoever liked it though.

Dean: Yeah, MySpace, what the hell is that? Seriously, is that some kind of porn site? - SN

reply

I personally prefer "A Cinderella Story" it has a lot of magic and is my favorite movie... I don't know if Hilary is talented as an actress, but if she is, she haven't shown it yet.
"A Cinderella Story" has somethig special. Chad Michael Murray is cast as Austin Ames and he is doing a great job as beeing the nicest guy in the world. Hilary is doing fine as Sam, as Cinderella, as the girl with the pure heart. And there is so much pink in this movie. It's just magic!

reply

I'd say Austin was a bit a dweeb. It's amazing that some so spineless could ever be considered the leader of any group of people, but whatever. It's just a movie.

reply