Mermaids


Did anyone else notice how much of the plot was borrowed from the movie Mermaids? I thought it was really similar, but lightened up a bit.

Check out my website:
http://brocka.f2o.org/childstar_fans/index.php

reply

I was going to post the same thing -that I liked this movie a lot better when it was called Mermaids. The only difference is the hair color.

reply

Just saw Mermaids and was going to say the same thing.

reply

As soon as I saw the first scene, I thought "wow, winona, cher, and christina did this sooooo much better". I figured that it was the same thing from the beginning.

~^*Angel Of Rock*^~

reply

I have never seen Mermaids but I have heard of it. Seen Trailors and adds.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I thought mermaids was an awful film.

I have nothing to say and I'm saying it and that is poetry

reply

You know, I've heard a lot of people say the two movies are similar, but I just don't see it. The Perfect Man was definitely a lot lighter, and in Mermaids, the mother and daughter had a much more abnormal relationship. That's not to say that Holly and Jean didn't have their issues, but it was just different.

Also, in Mermaids, the much younger sister was the person who helped keep the mother and older daughter together, since they both loved her, and she was "the one thing they agreed on." That wasn't a main premise at all in The Perfect Man. To say nothing of the fact that Hilary Duff and Winona Ryder did not play the same kind of character at all.

I'm not trying to bash those who find some similarities. Heck, I haven't even seen Mermaids in a really long time, so maybe I need to watch it again to form a better opinion.

reply

I have to say that I noticed several similarities but with a whole lot of rom com goodness mixed in.

reply

This was a rip off Mermaids, and yeah to the poster that said they thought Mermaids was an awful movie? Well that just tells me how low your IQ is.

reply