MovieChat Forums > Speak (2004) Discussion > is there ever a situation

is there ever a situation


to where the person who is rapped is to blame for what's happened? Just looking for openions here.

reply

Some people think there is. Such people are morons.

You can certainly paint a scenario where a rape victim behaves in an unwise fashion, or you could even imagine a scenario where they might even be considered to have invited or provoked their assault - just as happens with other forms of assault. The rapist/attacker remains responsible for their actions, however.

Imagine, if we were talking about a man punching a woman half his size in the face, instead of having sex with her. How much discussion would people be willing to even consider about the possibility of the woman being to blame?

Of course, a woman might easily insult, abuse or verbally antagonise a man into punching her - but she could only then be 'to blame' if you consider punching somebody to be a fair and reasonable response... and it would still be assault.

If I punch somebody, or forcibly have sex with them, my actions are my responsibility, regardless of any provocation - real or imagined.

reply

Thank you. this is helpful. Does anyone have any other openions?

reply

[deleted]

ffeff. I'm just trying to get people's inputs. I'd love to read what you think about the question, but if all you have to comment on is the grammar and spelling, go waist your life some where else.

reply

[deleted]

going on a Rant about grammar is a WASTE of time. Thank you for your input. I asked because I was watching Houndog. In that movie she gets nakid and dances for a young man. That movie make me wonder people's thoughts on the matter.

reply

[deleted]

Thank you I'll look into it.

reply

Of course not. All it take is the slightest humanity to realise that the victim should not be held accountable for crimes inflicted upon them. Would you ever say a murder victim is to be blamed for being killed? It's the same with being raped. Only heartless morons would say a rape victim is to to blame.

reply

^this. thank you.

reply

A person doesn't 'get raped'. Rape is something that is done to that person. It is done to young girls and old women and even men. Even if you don't know it, there's a high chance that someone you've met has been raped, molested or sexually assulted.

Rape isn't an accident.Yes, there are some behaviours and situations that can be considered more risky, but rape isn't preventable by anyone other than the rapist.

Yet, all we seem to here is "don't get raped". How about "Don't rape."

reply

It mostly happens with child molesters. Some parents actually blame the children for what happened, that is dreadful, the worst thing you can do. But if your parents are loving and understanding and all, they'll know it wasn't the child's fault they were or were almost raped, touched or any situation with a child molester.

No Day But Today. Today 4 U. One Song Glory.
How we gonna pay last year's RENT?!

reply

When a guy gets raped. He's blamed every time it seems.

reply


I don't believe a woman ever is to blame for being raped. That is the perpetrator's fault.
But I do believe a woman can invite trouble for herself in certain ways.
Going off alone to his place with a man you don't know for example.
Its not inviting rape, but its flirting with danger and the best way to avoid getting attacked is to take as many precautions as you can.


"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

Most rape victims are blamed for it by at least one person in their lives.

reply

[deleted]

No. As far as I'm concerned, you could walk down the street naked and no one would be justified in raping you. Prostitutes can be raped even if they have multiple partners and get paid for it on a regular basis. No one ever has the right to have sex with another person once they've said or demonstrated that they don't want to, and this includes incredibly wasted people, or people who have passed out. Common sense should be enough, but sadly it's not!

reply

NO.

reply