MovieChat Forums > He Knew He Was Right (2004) Discussion > The same actors in every show??

The same actors in every show??


Is it me or does every BBC drama of the past 5 years involve the same cast of actors?

Just started watching He Knew He was Right (2004 tv show) and it features practically the whole casts of Lark Rise to Candleford, Cranford, State of Play, Ashes to Ashes and Talk to Me (the first 2 being period dramas, the last 3 suspense-type series).

It's like there are 20 actors in Britain, a handful of extras - and everyone else has to move to LA in order to ever get a part.

reply

Well I wish Laura Fraser was in them all.

reply

Maybe there is a limited pool of actors who have the 1800s "look"? Not everyone has the body type or vibe to pull off the Victorian feel. The men can't be too bulky/muscly, tan or groomed. The women can't be too busty, muscled or cosmetically altered.

I've seen the actress who play Mrs. French, Barbara Flynn, the mother, in both period pieces and modern shows. I like her better in 1800s garb.




No two persons ever watch the same movie.

reply

The extremely tall girls who played the American fiance of Glascock wasn't very believable, I think.

What does this have to do with the premise of this threaD? Nothing, but it's more of a reply to the comment about looking the Victorian part. She does not. Far too tall.

The girl who plays NOra is so beautiful. But the, the girl who played the lead, Emily, is gorgeous, too.

reply

Funny you mentioned the American girl, Caroline Spalding, as she stood out like a sore thumb to me! I wondered if she was a British actress trying to do an American accent, because something wasn't quite natural about her. Turns out she is Anna-Louise Plowman, a graduate of the London Academy of Music and Dramatic Art, but originally from New Zealand.

On another side note, she is apparently married to Toby Stephens (Edward Rochester in Jane Eyre 2006) and her mother-in-law is Maggie Smith! Again, this is all OT from the thread, but makes for interesting trivia.

reply

@hanna house: That was bugging me too! It's not just the accent, I think, but the way the dialogue is written.

reply

It's the way she pronounces the word aristocrat. (Like an English person, not like an American.) And she over-emphasizes her R's the way a Canadian does. (English actors trying to do an American accent always make this mistake.)

reply

There were no tall people in Victorian times?

reply

Is it me or does every BBC drama of the past 5 years involve the same cast of actors?

It's you.

reply

As a big period drama person, I've often noticed recurring actors in period pieces. Though it doesn't bother me, in fact I quite like it!

In this one specifically, I've seen the actors from: The Man in the Iron Mask, Casanova, A Knights Tale, Tess of the D'Urbervilles, Poriot, The Importance of Being Earnest, Mansfield Park, I Capture the Castle, Anna and the King, Emma, Jane Eyre, Lost in Austen, Northanger Abbey, Rebecca, Alice in Wonderland, Lark Rise to Candleford, The Way We Live Now, The Forsyte Saga, Pride and Prejudice, Cranford, Miss Potter, Lorna Doone, Hamlet, Gosford Park, Stage Beauty, The Other Boleyn Girl, Little Dorrit and Vanity Fair.

I disagree with the idea that actors look right for the period, I think that people can be miscast and then look wrong in the part, but I think it an odd notion that people can *look* period, there are different fashions in beauty but that isn't the same thing in my opinion.

What I’ve always thought, is that some actors like period stuff and others don't same as other people, I'm not an actor but would love to be in a period thing, where as I know people who couldn't care less. As a viewer, if some one is adapting one of my favourite novels, I would appreciate if the actors had at least read it and didn't hate it.


I would have a signature but I don't know what to put

reply

But these 20 sure know how to act. BTW I didn't see any of them in North & South (the BBC production, not the Patrick Swayze one). Oh, and I didn't see them in Bleak House either...or in Downton Abby. Maybe there ARE more than 20 good actors in England!

reply

I'm on some kind of 'period piece world tour' and have been watching quite a few English films including this, The Forsyte Saga and Daniel Deronda, to name a few and this post immediately came to mind! Not quite the same cast but enough familiar faces to give credence to this thread, unfortunately.

__________
Have you held your hostage today?.

reply

In the director's commentary on the Notting Hill DVD, Richard Curtis says that actors in England all know each other because they work together all the time. I think Elizabeth McGovern says something similar in one of her Downton Abbey interviews on PBS.com.

reply

It’s because they don’t get locked down to 5+ year contracts. They have shorter tv series and actors have time to work on other projects.

reply

It's just a smaller industry.

reply