Did I miss something?


So many questions:
Why was the shoe a fiasco? What was so bad about it?
Why was he alone on the flight?
Why wouldn't Claire just let him sleep?
Why weren't his sister and mother coming with him?
How did the townspeople know it was him driving into town?
Why did the townspeople/relatives blame the mom for the fact they moved away, as if the dad had no will of his own?
Why did her husband's death make the mom want to learn all that stuff?
Who on this or any other planet turn a memorial service into a standup comedy routine? And why would such a crass act win over the people who didn't like her?
Why did the band keep playing when the room was catching on fire?
How long was that damn phone call between the lovebirds and yet their cellphones didn't run out of juice?
Finally,
Why did Claire keep popping up and flirting with him, only to then push him away or into the friend zone? And after she had done that one too many times, why would he care if he ever saw her again?

reply

Why ???

Because it's a movie. Your questions indicate that you expect a movie to represent normal live. How boring would that be.

-------------------------------------------
What if this is as good as it gets?

reply

Regarding your first point: I thought I missed something, too. What happened with the shoes!?

reply

There wasn't anything particularly wrong with them.

It was just that the company invested a bilion dollars in research, production and advertising for them....and it turned out no one liked them and they were a huge financial flop.

Not sure how that is all just Drew's fault, but "movies".

reply

Why was the shoe a fiasco? What was so bad about it?




There were apparently two versions of this movie. Late film critic, Roger Ebert viewed a version of the movie, where they explained the problem with the shoes. The shoes whistled:



http://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/elizabethtown-2005





reply

And in that version of the movie, the shoes apparently became a cult phenomenon and selling well at the end.

reply

Apparently, you missed multiple things...

lol jk I'll try to answer as best I can

1)I think it was just because they invested a lot of money into the company to have the shoe fiasco flop (like another person said).

2)Because it was just an empty flight? Not many people travel that late at night to somewhere south I'm assuming.

3)Which part? The plane or the morning after they have sex? If it's the second then because she wanted him to stop her before leaving.

4)I guess the sister didn't have time with her family and trying to console their mother. The mother didn't go because she said the family didn't like her.

5)They probably called before he flew over to let them know, and they just recognized him.

6)Because they loved the son and didn't care to blame him, they always blame the woman.

7)Maybe she felt like she didn't get to experience new things because she spent all her time with her husband and never had a chance to learn anything.

8)She maybe felt like people there thought she was too uptight and maybe her showing off her personality would win approval. Personality goes a long way.

9)Idk, they were just in the moment.

10)They had little flip phones back then. The battery on those phones lasted way long than the phones we use nowadays.

11)I don't think she pushed him into the friendzone, I think he pushed her. She liked him right away and everytime she seemed interested, he didn't. That's what maybe made her push him away.

reply

I know most of the questions have been answered, but I'll answer some from my point of view:

1. Someone mentioned that the shoes whistled, but I honestly have to wonder how the company invested almost a billion dollars in a new product without testing it first. I'd say that was as much the company's fault as the designer's.

2. It was probably a red-eye domestic flight, probably mid-week, so most likely pretty empty.

3. During the flight? She seemed to be very attuned to people's feelings, she probably felt he was very low and wanted to try and cheer him up. There's even a theory that Claire was actually an angel sent to help Drew.

4. His sister said she couldn't go because of the baby. I'm guessing when you have a newborn baby you can't just pick up and fly across the country in a few hours, she eventually made her way to Elizabethtown, I'm guessing after she made the proper arrangements. His mom also had to make arrangements and call people. They also wanted to have him cremated and his ashes sent to them, since his mom didn't seem to like the family, nor did they like her, she was probably trying to avoid them altogether.

5. It's supposed to be a small town, everyone knew Mitch, and they probably knew his son was coming into town for the funeral. I once drove into a really small town (it was in Mexico though, but I'm guessing small towns are pretty much the same everywhere) and kids everywhere ran towards my car and started pointing out where to go.

6. They seemed to be a very tight-knit community, and it's easier to say "oh that woman took him away from us" instead of admitting he left on his own, because then they'd have to admit that he didn't love them enough to stay there.

7. After over 30 years of being tied to one person, she probably wanted to get to know herself as a single woman again, she gave up years of her life raising children and making a home for her husband, so when he died, she had an identity crisis and wanted to learn how to be independent again.

8. She was trying to honor his memory, he was a guy who was always happy and cheerful, the life of the party, after my grandmother died, we all gathered at my house, and all her children (my dad, uncles and aunts) told stories about her, some funny, some not, but we laughed a lot the day of the funeral, there's nothing wrong with laughing. And she maybe won them over because she spoke to them from the heart and related to them more than ever I think.

7. Because they probably wanted to be all cool and be like "hey, remember that one time we played during a fire?"

8. I think there was a scene during the long phone call where one of them is plugging their phone into the charger, that's the beauty about mobile phones, not to mention they're old phones, our current phones run out of juice in half a day, but phones 10 years ago could go days without charging.

9. She had a crush on him, but at the same time she was afraid of commitment IMHO. And there's even a thing that women do sometimes where they want to hook a guy, they play the mysterious card and push a guy away after reeling him in, not all women do this, and not all guys fall for it, but some guys like the chase, I'm guessing Drew was one of those guys, I mean he was super hooked on Ellen even though she seemed to barely tolerate him.

Anyway that's my take on the situation, I've watched this movie so many times I think I've over-analyzed it way too much.
----------------------------
Never forget what you are, the rest of the world will not.

reply