I think you described A LOT of teenage girls (dramatic, insecure, etc.) so that part is not very surprising. Also she went through a lot as a 16/17 year old-losing two moms, basically living on her own, having the responsibilities that attic demanded, having a stalker, yes lol some of these things are ridiculous but it's a drama TV show.
I'm not really sure what you're referring to when you say "one minute she'll love someone and the next minute she'll walk away." Are you talking about Lucas here?
And yes in S5 Peyton was bitchy and immature at times but she lost the love of her life in a very crappy way, imo, and you have to remember she's still pretty young, 21/22 here. It wasn't right but I feel like it's understandable she'd be irrational at times.
So no, I don't have a hard time believing someone would fall for her. Especially someone like Lucas, who is the super sensitive, caring type that wants to basically rescue a girl, which we know he did plenty of. Besides him and Jake it's not like she had guys lined up around the block waiting to be with her. She's a complicated girl and it doesn't surprise me at all that those guys fell for her.
reply
share
amazingm08
8 years ago
Like I said Peyton is that type of girl who date once and that's it I get she's an incesure person and I also understand that tragedy struck her every time but she really has no excuse to act the way she did espically when she could've avoided it but instead acted like a high school girl at age 22 and thinks she has the right to call out people's promises Lucas isn't exactly the most loyal person around but he wasn't someone who was gonna let someone control his life all because they don't know what they want, and I commended him when he felt Peyton dissappeared from his life after high school and chose to move on with his life Honestly her little temper tantrum would've been it I would've cut ties and moved on
reply
share
amazingm08
8 years ago
She's that type of girl who cries about how hard her life is but does nothing to better herself or just make it worse
reply
share
kem7696
8 years ago
I agree with you on the part about Peyton and her HS years, to me alot of teens are moody and bitchy, so that doesn't really bug me.
As for her in S5, I can't make any excuses for her horrible behavior. I know she was 21/22 but she acted really bad. I never loved or hated Peyton, but S5 I couldn't stand her.
I don't have a hard time believing someone could love her either, but she was a nice person and had a big heart. Even thought I'm not a P&L fan at all, i can see they are sorta the same person so it would make sense for them to be together.
reply
share