MovieChat Forums > Art School Confidential (2006) Discussion > The 'mistake' slide in art history class...

The 'mistake' slide in art history class?


When Anjelica Huston was doing her "What is art?" speech for the introduction to the class, she pauses on a snapshot of her with a man who had white hair (and beard, if I remember right?). One student inquires whom it is, to which Huston turns around remarks on it being a mistake and moves on in the presentation.

Is there something on the DVD commentary that explains what happened there or who that was or should we just assume it's another part of this movie that goes unexplored like many of the intricate little characters, themes, and such?

reply

I assumed that she simply got a vacation photo mixed in with the class slides. She didn't actually look at the slide until the student asked what it was. I think the sequence was just a throwaway joke.


Movies I've Seen: http://imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=25003655

reply

I actually stopped the movie and went back to see if I'd missed something.

I hadn't...

reply

The idea is that Huston's character is trying to make the students question their definition of 'art' by asking if various paintings/photos could be considered art. But, the piece that most questions the standard definition of art (a simple snapshot) is a mistake. It's a comment on how art teachers pretend to understand all forms of art and to be open to looking at any work as a piece of art, but actually completely disregard any artwork that doesn't have some sort of novel value. More direct pieces of art like the snapshot and Jerome's drawings are treated like *beep* while gimmicky works like Jonah's or Eno's paintings are looked at more seriously.

reply

SixteenHorsepower, you remind me of Eno.

reply

If you look really closely the man in the picture is professor David Zipkin, the one who is on stage with Marvin Bushmiller. Huston's character was probably involved with him but didn't want the students to know. That was my interpretation.

reply

[deleted]

Excellent observation. But wasn't Professor Zipkin supposedly gay? That's what Marvin alludes to when he talks about him "trolling the halls"? Or maybe that's what made the relationship a mistake.

This film had a lot of those subtleties that could be read one way or another, or just ignored if you're not in the mood for analysis.

reply