MovieChat Forums > America's Next Top Model (2003) Discussion > Most Shocking/Upsetting Eliminations?

Most Shocking/Upsetting Eliminations?


Paige was totally robbed last night. Here are some other eliminations that just didn't make sense to me.

Sara (2)-she was in the bottom 2 with Yoanna the week she went home. Yoanna totally bombed the music video they had to do. Although I do think Yoanna is more high fashion than Sara, based on the task they were given that week, Yoanna should've gone home.

Norelle (3)-she had a great tmobile/kimono photo the week she was sent home. Ann & Yaya had weaker photos. Norelle had a really great look and I would've liked to have seen her in the anime motorcycle shoot.

Lisa (5)-this one still haunts me to this day. Her phone booth shot was gorgeous. Jayla had one of the most pictures in top model history that week.

Felicia (8)-her dead shot wasn't amazing, but her personality and other photos were great. I honestly think she was sent home because Tyra didn't like being told that they looked alike all the time.

Lisa (9)-both her and Heather had horrible commercials, but at least Lisa didn't have to be spoon fed the lines. Lisa had WAY more potential to be a real working model.

Katarzyna (10)-the fact that Whitey and Dominique out lasted her is a travesty. She is one of the most modelesque girls in the shows entire history. She was in the bottom two with Whitney the week she was sent home. Whitney had already been in the bottom a million times and it was VERY clear that they wanted a plus size winner regardless if they were good or not.

Monique (16)-She was a bit snotty, but I loved all of her photos and she had a way better portfolio than Mikaela.

AzMarie (18)-eliminated because of a butt pad. Ridiculous.

Brittany (19)-Victoria was mentally unstable and only took one good photo during her entire time there (the nude shot with Rob). Brittany had way more potential and a better look overall.

Lenox (21)-If Tyra hadn't thrown out the social media vote at the last second, Lenox would've won the whole competition. She was a DEFIITELY better than Adam and had better pictures than Will. I love Will, don't get me wrong, but Lenox was amazing.

Lacey (22)-She should've been with Nyle as the final two. I would've preferred her to win as well. Nyle was great, but there was just something about Lacey that I absolutely loved.

Justine (23)-I hate that Rita told her she was too young when Marissa was the same age. Also her crowd surfing shot wasn't bad at all, her face was stunning in it. I wish she would've stayed longer.

Paige (23)-Coryanne has been in the bottom like 3 times now? She should've gone home. Paige was the total package. I'm so sad she's gone.

reply

Imho, Lacey and Mikey should have been the final 2 over Mame and Nyle. Mame and Nyle were the popular choice, but Mikey and Lacey had the better portfolios. Nyle is hot, don't get me wrong, but Mikey was a better model


Agree with you on Brittany. She should have been in the top 3 with Laura and Leila.

reply

Amazed no one has yet mentioned Brittney (Cycle 4). She had the best picture that week, the judges even agreed. Instead they eliminated her by claiming she "lost her spark", immediately after they told her to tone things down the week before.

reply

I totally agree about Laura, Leila and Brittany being the perfect final three for Cycle 19.

I agree about Brittany (Cycle 19)'s elimination. I saw it as a shock as I really expected her to go further.

reply