Yours, Mine, and Ours vs. Cheaper by the Dozen in a fight

Frank Beardsley vs. Tom Baker FRANK
Helen North vs. Kate Baker KATE
William Beardsley vs. Charlie Baker CHARLIE
Dylan North vs. Charlie Baker CHARLIE
Christina Beardsley vs. Lorraine Baker LORRAINE
Naoko North vs. Lorraine Baker LORRAINE
Phoebe North vs. Nora Baker NORA
Kelly Beardsley vs. Sarah Baker SARAH
Joni North vs. Sarah Baker SARAH
Harry Beardsley vs. Henry Baker HENRY
Jimi North vs. Jake Baker JIMI
Mick North vs. Mark Baker MICK
Marissa/Bina North vs. Kim/Jessica Baker KIM & JESSICA
Ely/Otter Beardsley vs. Kyle/Nigel Baker KYLE & NIGEL
Aldo North/Ethan Bearsley vs. Kyle Nigel KYLE & NIGEL
Michael Beardsley vs. Mike Baker MIKE
Lau North vs. Mark Baker MARK
Max (Jerry) vs. Hank (Ashton) MAX (Hank is weak)

The the fight, if the same actors are in both movies, I declare A TIE. How many child actor overlap do we have between the two movies?

Cheaper by Dozen better!

Awesome thread. The the Baker mom would mop the floor with the artsy-fartsy hippie mom, Helen North. It'd be kind of sad. Mrs. North would end up getting spanked.

And I think a better matchup for Lorraine would be Phoebe, played by Danielle Panabaker, also a hippie chick. Both Hillary and Dsnielle are ex Disney girls. I can imagine Phoebe stereotying Lorraine unfairly, and as a result, Lorraine who is much stronger, ripping into Phoebe with head punches, gut punches, and finally giving Phoebe a literal kick to the butt. No contest.

I would have to say that I liked Cheaper by the Dozen (2003) better than Yours, Mine and ours (2005).

Both of these movies are remakes. The original Yours, Mine, and Ours was a great movie. It was much better than the 2005 remake. I like the remake of Cheaper by the Doze better than the original, but I want to watch the original over again. The original is based on a true story. It has some funny moments. It's kind of sad, though.