MovieChat Forums > Deadwood (2004) Discussion > When Doc Cochran dies will he be replace...

When Doc Cochran dies will he be replaced?


The last time we see Doc Cochrane he was looking rather blue in the face, so to speak. I suspected he was coming down with TB? Tuberculosis. It was inevitable what would happen post-series. He's a goner.

With that said, do you think Al Swearengen will have him replaced with a new doctor? Or do you think the relationship between Al and Cochrane was so symbiotic that he just wouldn't bother getting a new doctor out of respect for Cochrane?

Also, how much would Doc Cochran's death effect Al?

Thoughts?

_______________________
PDBPO LEADER 

reply

I can't speak to what might happen if/when Doc dies, but I suspect that if Milch were to have him die it'd be with more fanfare than just saying he passed away in the interim between Season 3 and the movie.

I believe that Doc was at least partly based on Milch's own father, a troubled but brilliant surgeon whom Milch had very complicated feelings about but ultimately loves deeply. I think this bears itself out in the character of Doc -- like Elmer Milch, an alcoholic with a hell of a temper at times: perhaps not a saint, but at heart a compassionate and decent man. So I'd imagine that Milch would lend a lot of screen-time to Doc's actual death, and perhaps intended to do so in the fourth season.

Depending on how much time the movie will say elapsed since Season 3, it's possible Doc could still be alive, on death's door, and his passing could even be a big part of the narrative thrust of the thing.

I don't know -- Doc was such an integral part of the town and the series. He was, in a way, like the heart of the show. It's difficult to imagine him dying and the show going on without him, so I'd imagine this would occur near the end of the movie (or season if that had come to pass).

Of course this is all hoping a movie will indeed happen, anyway. Fingers crossed...

reply

FWIW, TB was not a forgone death sentence. Mortality was high, but it was still survivable.

reply