Fight between Souls


I wonder what you guys think about this theory.

First, Remove Zach from the equation, cos his being in it makes the already swiss-cheese plot even worse. Let's start simply.

If you believe that each body has a soul, and when a person dies under certain extreme circumstances, or simply had a very powerful personality in life, their spirit does not cross over to wherever the hell it's supposed to go, gets stuck in-between, and wanders as some knd of ghost. Then could this entire thing not just be explained as Adam1's ghost seeing his own body essentially alive agaian as Adam2? Adam1 (being the rightful owner) is lost, angry, alone and trying to get it back? Thus causing the apparent fight over control of Adam2's consciousness? Perhaps that is helped by the belief that God only "assigns" one soul per body, and cloning screw with some kind of divine rule, thue leaving the body open to be fought over by displaced wandering souls (those damn ghosts, again).

With the Zach bit added, that doesn't work so well, unless in the process of cloning and monitoring Adam2, the doctor performed some kind of genetic cognitive/memory creation, or even hypnotic suggestion to implant false memories or personality traits, in an attempt to save a small poart of his own child (Zach), which then goes horribly wrong.

Damn. You know it's a bad movie when nobody can come up with a likely, (much less believable) scenario for what the hell the writers were trying to accomplish here! :)

-K

Me - IMDB http://imdb.com/name/nm1485711/
--------[fear the bitchy clone]-------

reply

Sounds good!

Phil: I'm gonna be on you like a shadow!
Will: but with you it's more like an eclipse right?

reply

When Hollywood has an evil "pictures everywhere" psycho room, there generally isn't much of a total explanation, and some of the freaks nowadays figure all the occult stuff is probable,so they mishmashed everything together, like including the doctor clacking together the 2 steel benwa balls to the tune of the ghostly footsteps at the river with the ax going into the head as dr mengele dropped the steel voodoo orbs to the floor.
Since he was "playing by the river" with someone he wasn't supposed to tell about, it seems the ghost of Zachary theory is good.
Plus we have the resplendent theme of the poor schoolchild who "was made fun of by other kids and lashed out in response".
I guess the Hollywooders are inwardly tortured by the "opinions and put downs of their peers and critics" that are diametrically opposed to their gigantic personal overblown egos, so they project their own pain and current life existence onto " the poor child who is made fun of by classmates " and lashes out in bloody ax slayings or shootings or burnings.

I think the wackos of our modern society have an entire legal edifice and foundation of excuses built upon that idea, that abuse begets abuse, and the murderer is the victim, that's why we have the mommie constantly berating greggy for being a meanie to the child and grabbing and protecting him in this film.
Hollywood can't get past it's own modern socio-stereotypes and political agendas ( which as some have pointed out include the "cloning is bad" in this film, and the mystical world of ghosts and past lives, with the lynchpin of "personal identity" that aggregates the need for the massive ego of self, and self-esteem coddling and tenderizing.

reply

I really thought it would be more along those lines, like a child version of Flatliners.. Much disappointment.

reply