MovieChat Forums > The Notebook (2004) Discussion > Ever been left because of money like Noa...

Ever been left because of money like Noah?


I have. Ex ended up with a guy making 150k a year so she got her wish. Haven't even tried dating since and that was a year and a half ago because I feel like I'll never meet another one like her. I really don't understand how money can trump the heart and soul and feelings one has for another.

reply

Couple of thoughts:

Maybe the money isn't the only reason why she left. It could be some of the reason but not the only one. You might not like hearing that but it's possible.

Do you have any idea if she's really happy now that she made that decision?

It's possible she might regret it.

In the movie, Ally came back to Noah after all so how can you say he was left for money? She returned to him and left the money behind.

reply

And Flicky-3, who on earth do you think you are? People sticking up for morally rotten women need to stop. A cheating or golddigging tramp is just as bad as her male equivalent, the fact that she has a vagina doesn't change her rotten soul.

reply

I don't mean to sound like I'm sticking up for her.

I just suspect there could be some other issues besides the money factor.

Back to the actual movie, are you suggesting that Allie is a cheating/gold-digging tramp? I don't think so but I'd be interested to hear your thoughts.

Sorry for your personal situation by the way.

reply

[deleted]

Me too, man. The guy I was engaged to found some filthy rich lady to take care of him a few months before our wedding. I was so in love with him that I didn't notice how money-driven he was. I'm not rich- I try my best in life, I have my own business after working hard to be able to do that, I bought a small house and I can pay for all that I could want and still save up, but I guess it just wasn't enough for him. I was the one doing all the things a man "should" do (according to society's norms anyway)- working, saving up, buying a house and a car and all those things. On top of that I would wash, clean and cook for him everyday even though we weren't living together yet. He would lean back and relax. And all of that wouldn't have mattered, everything I did for him came from my heart and were acts of love. I just can't handle it that he picked an older, not so attractive woman for her money over a woman who was 10 years his junior, quite attractive (if I say so myself) and willing to do whatever to make him happy. I'm heartbroken even though It's been two years ago. I'll probably never date again, I thought that what he and I had was real and I loved him so, so much. I'll never let that happen to me again.

reply

Haven't even tried dating since and that was a year and a half ago because I feel like I'll never meet another one like her


Why would you want to meet someone like her again? If she left you so easily, what is there to admire about her or torture yourself over? Just a thought.

reply

What are you talking about? She didn't leave him because of money. She was physically forced to leave by her parents. She was maybe 16, after all. He wrote her every day, and Mom stole the letters.

And, after all, she came back despite being engaged to Mr.Gotbucks. who her parents LOVED! She came back to love. Money didn't mean a damn thing. You're mistaking what Allie's mother did for what she did -- and even that was coerced.

reply

[deleted]

So, here's this thing. Seems far fetched AT FIRST, but stick with me: Society has gotten SO TWISTED due to the industrial revolution, that men are no longer killing buffalo, bringing home food, and providing a cave to be safe in. Now, that killing, the food, and cave are ALL - and I mean >>ALL<< inclusive within the frameworkings of "MONEY". The female species' "providing mate" dynamic is NOW based on money for protection, sustenance, and power.

"Gold diggers" are evolutionarily not wrong. Regardless of our superficial judgements, they are closer to our true self than we want to admit. Deep down they seek: the confidence(protective power), food, and shelter.... = money. So, tell me why that is wrong now? Are we going to go back to manually killing buffalo? I seriously doubt it. :)

reply