MovieChat Forums > The Punisher (2004) Discussion > This movie was difficult to watch for so...

This movie was difficult to watch for so many reasons.


First off Thomas Jane was a huge miscast as the punisher. He had a pussiness about him that ruined the movie for me. The stupid sidekicks and romantic interest all were horrible. The acting over all was horrible except for Travolta who nailed it.

Save your time and watch Punisher War Zone.







Virgins. I love em. No diseases, no loose as a goose pussy, no skank. No nothin. Just pure pleasure!

reply

*spoilers*
You're tripping.
Sad that you are so woefully unfamiliar with the character, Punisher.
This was played well. The story is great. There are NO romantic entanglements.... soooooo, you straight made that up.
He's cold & unfeeling, the PERFECT Punisher. He does NOT kiss Jane "the mouse", in the end- despite her obvious crush.
Instead delivering that incredible quip about: "if you want to know how I'm doing, read a paper. The obituaries."
Whereas, in the hunk of garbage you recommend, the soft ass little girl of a Punisher lets his guard down because he's busy "playing house" at his "hideout", & lets the bad guys get a jump on him. It is the OPPOSITE of the Frank Castle character. Period.

reply

*Spoiler*
YOU'RE tripping.
I have been a fan of this character for over 30 years now, and this movie and the portrayal of the character were terrible beyond words. So sorry, you're "woefully unfamiliar" tag doesn't fit on me.
Bad taste in movies. Period.

reply

you ever read the comic this film was based on? Year One was written in the mid 90s and Frank was also a drunken and sullen mess in it. At one point in that story he was crying in a bed of forget me nots. Sh1 t was corny. And a little bit of cheesiness seems to be part of the character's essence no matter who's writing him.

While Ennis brought the character up to date in the early 2000s the action in some of his arcs of the Max comics were hilarious yet equally stupid at times with overdone cartoon like deaths and portrayal of the antagonists as one dimensional dimwits. While this film was like a love letter to the very 80s action flicks that the character embodied until the early 2000s, it managed to combine some of the better moments in both the Year One and Welcome Back Frank arcs. It has a cult following and got more than a few folks to appreciate the character and become fans. The movie after it didn't do much better.

reply

Dude the movie was good. I was able to watch it all

reply

I was taking your comments seriously and then you said to watch War Zone.

reply

+10,000!!!

reply

I think both Jane and Stevenson are great punishers

reply

AGREE...I ENJOYED TH PUNISHER IN THEATERS AND WAS PLEASANTLY SURPRISED BY WAR ZONE ON HOME VIDEO.

reply

WarZone is a popcorn flick for me but they got the gore and violence down. Stevenson did a great job
Its worthwhile in the end.

reply

EXACTLY..RAY STEVENSON WAS PERFECT.I HAD SEEN HIM IN THE OUTPOST,BUT WASNT EXPECTING MUCH FROM WARZONE..DUDE THREW THE FLICK ON HIS SHOULDERS AND POWERED ON...

reply

the scene at the family dinner in warzone is the shit and when dude does the flip then boom lmao!

reply

i saw both in theatres! war zone kicked ass to me dont know why it gets so much shit yea jigsaw was laughable but it was an enjoyable action flick!

reply

i was sorta OK with Thomas Jane
agree that Travolta was phenomenal as always

reply