Historical Inaccuracies


Let me start off by saying that I was a big fan of AD when it was on the air, and I taped every episode. But it was obvious to me even at the time, that alot of the stories had historical inaccuracies, especially when it came to Vietnam. I realize, of course, that the writers probably played with the facts intentionally, to make the stories more dramatic and to move things along.

For instance, I recall the parts of Seasons 1 and 2 set in 1964-1965, which depict alot of the characters as being anti-war, engaging in protests, and Nathan going to jail rather than being drafted.

First of all, while the U.S. forces were in Vietnam since the 1950s, we didn't engage in any real military offensives until early 1965. In 1964, there weren't wide spread anti-war protests or people going to jail, like Nathan, because the war hadn't really erupted. In 1964, it wasn't a major issue for most Americans.

In fact, the protests that began in 1965, were not large scale demonstrations, and they were mostly confined to a few of the bigger college campuses. In '65, the anti-war movement was small, most Americans supported the war, and the events you saw on American Dreams didn't really take place until later in 1966 onwards.

reply

I don't mean to sound like a bitch but who the hell cares? They didn't have neatly enough time to accurately depict these years so some things that happened later in real life happened earlier on the show. Anyone who watches a show set in the '60s wants to see a good anti war protest and this show was on the bubble every year. They didn't know when it would end and I suspect they really wanted to bring Meg's anti war stance to the forefront so they used creative licensing. Same thing with the music because plenty of songs played on the show were historically inaccurate in terms of when they were actually released or put on the radio.

reply

You didn't want to,but then you did.
And since I lived through the 60s,I didn't really tune in to "see a good anti war protest".
Some of us lived through them.
You obviously did not.

reply

That's how it was in "The '60s" movie. Jerry O'Connell's character went into Vietnam when it was about '63. It could've been '62 even. I think honestly the producers knew the show was on the fritz with ratings, so they crammed in a lot and therefore had to fudge dates.

reply

yes I know the did. Same thing with the illegal abortion episode. My dad was JJ's age and attended catholic school then....unlike today, the church did not actively campaign against abortion.

Helen would not have said anything to Amy about it. Actually she would have just been grateful her class mate was not dead.

NBC threw that in as a proactive guard against current day affiliate etc pickets. They would have been screaming about it non-stop otherwise.

Other inaccuracy was Meg's hairdo. They did that so youth would/could relate to her--but it just looks out of place/time. She could have had a flip (like Roxanne) and would have looked fine. Meg looks like something from the 1980's/1990's.



reply