about the chickens


According to Wikipedia, the tagline for this move translates to "if you run, the beast catches; if you stay, the beast eats". Also, in the first scene, the narrator voice of Rocket says: "A picture could change my life, but... in the City of God, if you run away, they get you... and if you stay, they get you, too."

This quote immediately follows the opening where there are two chickens shown: one stands there passively and then gets grabbed and butchered. The other tries to run away, but is chased by a gang and eventually caught in the crossfire of the final shootout.

Given the tagline and opening quote, the chickens are clearly symbolic of a theme of the movie. Bené tries to escape the favela, but is caught in the crossfire between Blacky and Li'l Zé. Meanwhile, the Portuguese name for Knockout Ned is Mane Galinho which translates roughly to "Chicken Manny" who is just trying to go about his business passively (he doesn't have a gun and doesn't participate in the gangs), but he still gets sucked into the violence and eventually killed.

Rocket, on the other hand, doesn't try to escape the favela but also tries to avoid the gang violence. Thus he's a bit more like Ned than Bené, and could potentially get "eaten" -- yet in the end, it is left unclear whether his photography is going to allow him to eventually find an elusive "third way": staying in the CIty of God but being active enough to avoid being "eaten".

Anyway, I liked these aspects of symbolism very much in the movie. However, I didn't see what happened to the chicken in the chaos at the end. I'd be curious to know if it's fate shown in any of the closing battle scenes. (By the time it occurred to me to look for this, I no longer had the rental to rewatch the scenes.) Does anyone know?

reply

The chicken gets away...it ducks underneath the car and runs off, and that's when Rocket begins narrating.

Excellent analysis by the way, I never even thought there was symbolism to the chicken. Very interesting.

Even though its not particularly symbolic, the moment when Lil Ze dies reads as symbolic to me. The entire film it is established that Lil Ze is the boss, and that he massacred many people to reach the top and to stay on top- he is untouchable. The police won't even arrest him, as Knockout Ned says. And in the last moments, like any other worthless criminal in the movie, he gets gunned down by a bunch of kids in an alley. It's almost as if the movie portrayed Lil Ze as a god- or I suppose the devil really- and then killed him off like he was anything else.

Amazing movie.

reply

[deleted]

I agree with your analysis for the most part except the part about Knockout Ned "Galinho" in Portuguese is simply a slang term for an attractive guy. I wouldn't look to deeply into that.

reply

[deleted]

You are wrong. In Portuguese, the name of Knockout Ned is Mané Galinha, not Mané Galinho, and obviously do not have any sexual connotation or attraction. The name was changed because in English it would be cowardly connotation, which does not exist in Brazil.

reply