MovieChat Forums > Cidade de Deus (2004) Discussion > Most credible amateur acting ever?

Most credible amateur acting ever?


Watched it again last night and one thing that I always found amazing in this, was how the acting looks totally real and fluid. Most of them were amateurs who never really acted and you just feel you are watching real people. Amazing.

reply

Agreed my friend, it really was top notch!

reply

I thought the exact same thing. Really impressive.

reply

i agree! the acting was really really good overall.. but not sure they beat the two leads in Beasts of the Southern Wild when it comes to amateur acting
.

reply

Amazing movie, but it's not even close to the acting of the kids in KIDS. That was the best amateur acting I've seen.

reply

I was going to say in addition to City of God, KIDS had the best amateur acting I have ever seen.

reply

Yes.

reply

[deleted]

Agree! As someone else pointed out KIDS too was amazing. But if I had to pick between the two film I would choose City of God.


SPOILER



What was truly amazing was the scene when Lil Ze has the makes young kid who wants to join his gang choose then kill one of the runts. The acting of the one child who first gets shot in the foot and the look on the kids face who has to choose is remarkable. It was the most disturbing scene I have ever witnessed in a movie, amazing that the actor were all amateurs.

reply

That kid nailed it. I felt so sad for him, it was almost like he really thought he was about to die.

reply

Yep, amazing. You have Fatima Toledo to thank for that. She picked and trained all the actors right out of the street. Some I think were already actors/models, like Bene and his older brother, but the rest, that's just Fatima's work.

reply

For anyone who doesn't speak Portuguese it may sound like professional acting, but some of the line delivery was a bit off on some points. Also, due to the fact most of the dialogue is improvised, you can hear some slang words that were not part of the general vocabulary in the 60s and 70s.

"You keep him in here, and make sure HE doesn't leave!"

reply

What words?

They call me the Mayor, 'Cause I spend all my days here

reply