Why Gibson made this film


I saw Gibson on Oprah about 10 years ago and he said his favorite TV/Film of all time was The Singing Detective.

reply

I saw Gibson on Oprah about 10 years ago and he said his favorite TV/Film of all time was The Singing Detective.


I'm sure we all have a favourite aunt or uncle, but we don't go digging them up and dressing them in different clothes or using them as a hat-stand. Gibson's comment is understandable - the television series was jaw-droppingly good. His apparent need to recreate it and hubris at thinking he might have a shot at succeeding is less admirable.

Unfortunately, he probably liked Edge of Darkness a lot, too.

(P.S. The film wasn't BAD as such. It just wasn't necessary.)

reply

Dennis Potter wrote the script, so I don't think this was an unnecessary recreation.

reply

The British version didn't have Robert Downey Jr, who was brilliant (as always) in this version.





"Fasten your seat belts. It's going to be a bumpy night."

reply

I loved the original series and I thought the film was pretty damn good. Obviously a little more sketchy than the series, but kept all the main ideas and threw a different light on some aspects. A little like hearing a good cover version of one of your favourite songs, in fact.

reply

as I recall he did it as a Vehicle for Downey to highlight his abilities...

You need to remember How Big Gibson was at the Time, and how deep in the Hole Downey was ...

this film Predates Downey's Rise by the better part of 5 years... people tend to forget he was pretty 'toxic' especially as a Leading Man for quite a while before Ironman and Sherlock Holmes
-- 2001 saw him fired from Ally McBeal and sent to Court Ordered Rehab

reply

True Tjanssend411, he saved Downeys butt. And to this day Downey praises him for it. Actually, Mel did that for Brittney Spears and some other person, can't recall who right now.

The two of them in this film is hilarious. Knowing they are still best friends makes it all the better!



"Guys like you don't die on toilets." Mel Gibson-Riggs, Lethal Weapon

reply